“Thus, Arminianism made man’s salvation depend ultimately on man himself, saving faith being viewed throughout as man’s own work and, because his own, not God’s in him” (J.I. Packer, “Introduction” from “The Death of Death in the Death of Christ” by John Owen. London: Banner of Truth, 1959, pp. 3-4; quoted by David Steele, Curtis Thomas, and S. Lance Quinn in “The Five Points of Calvinism: Defined, Defended, and Documented, Second Edition.” Phillipsburg: P&R Publishing, 2004, page 3).
In yesterday’s post, I focused on Arminius’s words regarding the call of man to salvation. I showed in that post that God is the one who gets the praise for man’s salvation, from beginning to end; that, although man must receive the gift of salvation in order to be saved, Arminius never credits man with the work of salvation but instead gives glory to God. Before I get started again today, let me just say that I am surprised that J.I. Packer and other Calvinists are able to make such comments like the quote above in print for folks all over the world to see. And what’s so sad is that Calvinists are completely misguided when it comes to Classical Arminian theology...and most of the world just seems to focus on “foreseen faith” as the reason why they choose not to be Arminian, instead of reading Arminius for themselves and finding out whether or not he speaks truth. If you’ve ever picked up a copy of Arminius’s “Works” and thumbed through them long enough, you could not make the statement above that Packer makes; you would not be able to claim that Arminians hold to their theology because of “philosophical commitments”. Rather, we hold to the philosophy we do because of the Scriptures themselves. Our theology determines our philosophy, not the other way around.
In today’s post, I wanna talk on the topic of “The Divine Pleasure”: that is, What pleases God? What is God pleased to do in the world? If “God does whatever He pleases,” as the Calvinists say, then what pleases God? If we can look at the Scriptures and see what God does, then we can resolve within ourselves that God does what He does because it is pleasing to Him. After all, God is not bound by anyone or anything outside of Himself to do what He does; He is free to do as He so chooses (this is where Classical Arminians DO agree with our Calvinist brethren). In this sense, Classical Arminians, like Calvinists, hold to a form of “unconditional” election---that being, that God did not have to save anyone. He was not obligated to save us, since we are responsible for our sin in Adam (Rom. 5).
I’m gonna stick around Arminius’s words on “The Vocation of Men to Salvation” (Disputation XVI), which is where I came from yesterday. Regarding the way salvation is dispensed, Arminius writes the following:
“The Disposing Cause is the wisdom and justice of God; by which HE KNOWS HOW IT IS PROPER FOR THIS VOCATION TO BE ADMINISTERED, and wills it to be dispensed as it is lawful and befitting; and from which is formed the Decree of his will concerning the administration and its mode. (1 Cor. i,17,18.)” (Arminius, “Works,” II:232).
Why is salvation dispensed as a gift received by faith? Because this pleases God; the way salvation is granted to sinners is the way God saw fit to do things. If He had wanted to grant salvation another way, then He would have been free and right to do it another way. The fact that salvation comes the way it does testifies to the freedom of God, by which He is just in His doings.
In their description of “Unconditional Election,” Steele, Thomas,and Quinn write the following:
“The doctrine of election declares that God, before the foundation of the world, chose certain individuals from among the fallen members of Adam’s race to be the objects of His undeserved favor. These, and these only, He purposed to save. GOD COULD HAVE CHOSEN TO SAVE ALL MEN (FOR HE HAD THE POWER AND AUTHORITY TO DO SO) OR HE COULD HAVE CHOSEN TO SAVE NONE (FOR HE WAS UNDER NO OBLIGATION TO SHOW MERCY TO ANY)---but He did neither. Instead, He chose to save some and to exclude others. His eternal choice of particular sinners for salvation was not based upon any foreseen act or response on the part of those selected, but was based solely on His own good pleasure and sovereign will. Thus, ELECTION WAS NOT DETERMINED BY, OR CONDITIONED UPON, ANYTHING THAT MEN WOULD DO, BUT RESULTED ENTIRELY FROM GOD’S SELF-DETERMINED PURPOSE” (“The Five Points of Calvinism,” page 27).
It is no secret that David Steele, Curtis Thomas, and S. Lance Quinn are all Calvinist (at least Molinist) in their theology, since they argue for unconditional election. However (and this might shock most who read this), Classical Arminians ACTUALLY AGREE WITH THE ABOVE STATEMENT IN BOLD CAPS! We do not argue in our theology that God “had” to save us, nor do we argue that God “could not have done it any other way.” We believe that God could have left all of us drowning in sin, destined for Hell, and God would have been just in so doing. The Lord didn’t “owe” us salvation in any shape, form or fashion. This is the “Reformed” side of my theology on display.
BUT...and this is where my “Arminian” side comes out, we believe, contra Calvinists, that God decided to save man by the exercise of his God-given faith! While it certainly was a possibility of God’s to save certain persons, we don’t believe that God chose certain individuals and passed by others; rather, God decided to save or damn on the basis of faith. The classic passage of all time, John 3:16-18, tells us of the plan of God and His way of salvation: “He who believes in Him is not condemned; but he who does not believe is condemned already, because he has not believed in the name of the only begotten Son of God” (John 3:18, NKJV). Those who follow in the theology of James Arminius himself cannot say that God was obligated to save every single individual. This would be like saying that God was obligated to save every single Jew because of their ethnicity (Rom. 9), which is a ludicrous statement to make! God did not have to come for every person, but He did because this fit “the good pleasure of His will” (Eph. 1:9,11).
God administers salvation the way He does because “He knows how it is proper for this Vocation to be administered.” God saves on the basis of exercised faith because it seemed right to Him to do so. At this point, I’m going to be more nuanced in my view of election than most have ever presented election: while choosing us is “unconditional” on the part of God, who was not forced to save or choose any, election is “conditional” on the part of the individual, who can only be elect by faith in Christ. While Calvinists focus on the earlier verses of Ephesians 1 which say, “He chose us in Him before the foundation of the world” (v.4), they neglect latter verses in the same chapter such as Eph. 1:13---“In Him you also trusted, after you heard the word of truth, the gospel of your salvation; in whom also, having believed, you were sealed with the Holy Spirit of promise.” How does salvation come? First, a person hears the gospel (“after you heard the word of truth, the gospel”); then the person believes the gospel (“you also trusted...the gospel of your salvation”); last but not least, the person is sealed with the Holy Spirit (“having believed, you were sealed with the Holy Spirit of promise”).
Salvation is never recorded in the Scriptures as coming to us by some predetermined decree from eternity past that had certain names on a list that were labeled
“elect.” Salvation comes when one hears the word, understands it, and, grace going before (prevenient grace), exercises the faith the Spirit of Grace imparts to him or her to believe the gospel message. If God wanted it to be “already predetermined,” then what need would there even be for a gospel message? If God has already “singled out” the few He wants and damned the rest, who needs to believe any sort of gospel?
And this is where Calvinism is seen for the horrid theology it really is. Here is once more, what authors David Steele, Curtis Thomas, and S. Lance Quinn had to say about unconditional election:
“His eternal choice of particular sinners for salvation WAS NOT BASED UPON ANY FORESEEN ACT OR RESPONSE ON THE PART OF THOSE SELECTED, but was based solely on His own good pleasure and sovereign will” (“The Five Points,” page 27).
Notice the phrase in caps? Certain individuals were chosen, according to the writers, without regard to faith. But if this is true, then why is it that, according to Ephesians, that one must hear the word, believe, and THEN receive the Holy Spirit?
“In Him you trusted, after you heard the word of truth, the gospel of your salvation; in whom also, having believed, you were sealed with the Holy Spirit of promise” (Eph. 1:13).
Why must any of this occur if God chose to save “unconditionally”? To save “unconditionally” means to save without regard to anything within the creature, including the faith that God provides. So, if Calvinists like J.I. Packer wanna state that faith is a gift (which I too, believe), but God only provides faith to the elect ones, why then, must God provide faith? If God intends to regenerate sinners before they exercise God-given faith, then what is the faith needed for at all?
I suspect that Calvinists have spent too much time focusing on the “pre-creation decrees” of infralapsarianism and supralapsarianism...and not enough on the context of Ephesians chapter 1. Maybe it’s high time they do that...
a site dedicated to the exploration, analysis, and evaluation of various theological systems
Showing posts with label The Five Points of Calvinism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Five Points of Calvinism. Show all posts
Thursday, August 12, 2010
Wednesday, August 11, 2010
Getting the Story Straight, Pt. V-A: Soli Deo Gloria
“Thus, Arminianism made man’s salvation depend ultimately on man himself, saving faith being viewed throughout as man’s own work and, because his own, not God’s in him” (J.I. Packer, “Introduction” from “The Death of Death in the Death of Christ” by John Owen. London: Banner of Truth, 1959, pp. 3-4; quoted by David Steele, Curtis Thomas, and S. Lance Quinn in “The Five Points of Calvinism: Defined, Defended, and Documented, Second Edition. Phillipsburg: P&R Publishing, 2004, page 3).
Throughout this series of “Getting the Story Straight,” I’ve demonstrated that J.I. Packer is grossly incorrect in his analysis of Arminianism---that is, Arminians are not Pelagian in their theology. Here today, I return to correct another false statement Packer makes about Arminians: that is, that Classical Arminians fail to attribute glory to God...that we attempt to give glory to man for our salvation.
In his Disputation XVI, titled “On the Vocation of Men to Salvation,” Arminius wrote the following:
“We define vocation, A GRACIOUS ACT OF GOD IN CHRIST, by which, through his word and Spirit, He calls forth sinful men, who are liable to condemnation and placed under the dominion of sin, from the condition of the animal life, and from the pollutions and corruptions of this world, (2 Tim. i,9; Matt. xi, 28; 1 Pet. ii,9,10; Gal. i,4; 2 Pet. ii, 20; Romans x, 13-15; 1 Pet. iii,19; Gen. vi,3,) unto ‘the fellowship of Jesus Christ,’ and of his kingdom and its benefits; that, being united unto Him as their Head, they may derive from Him life, sensation, motion, and a plenitude of every spiritual blessing, TO THE GLORY OF GOD and their own salvation. (1 Cor. i,9; Gal. ii,20; Ephes. i,3,6; 2 Thess. ii,13,14)” (Arminius, “Works,” II:231-232).
Arminius deems the call to salvation (vocation) as “a gracious act of God in Christ”; here, we find that it is God’s kindness that brings this about. And this is where Classical Arminians agree with Calvinists: there is nothing outside of God that dictates His actions. God does what He pleases...and He is pleased to call men and women to faith, to grant them life everlasting. Without this benevolence from God, no man or woman could, or would be, saved. Secondly, note that Arminius labels man as unworthy of this call to salvation: “He calls forth sinful men, who are liable to condemnation and placed under the dominion of sin.” The words “sinful men,” “liable to condemnation,” and “under the dominion of sin” tell us what man is and what he deserves---nothing short of Hell itself. So if any man or woman goes to Heaven, it is of nothing they deserve, but of what God has graciously given. This is “Soli Deo Gloria,” a praise to God because only God deserves praise for man’s blessings and eternal bliss with Christ.
Examine the passages Arminius notes at the end of the above quote. In 1 Corinthians 1:9, it is God “by whom you were called into the fellowship of His Son, Jesus Christ the Lord” (NKJV); in Galatians 2:20, it is Christ whom, as Paul says, “loved me and gave Himself for me.” In Ephesians 1:3, it is God the Father “who has blessed us with every spiritual blessing in the heavenly places in Christ.” And who gets the praise for salvation and all its benefits? “to the praise of the glory of HIS GRACE, by which HE made us accepted in the Beloved” (Eph. 1:6). And in 2 Thess. 2:13-14, it is God who “from the beginning chose you for salvation through sanctification by the Spirit and belief in the truth.” It is God who gets the glory for the salvation of man. Arminius’s references to these verses demonstrates his great desire to give God glory for his salvation. Once again, this is “soli deo Gloria,” for the glory of God alone. Contra Packer, Classical Arminians do not give themselves glory for their salvation. I don’t know if Packer has ever read Arminius, but he and all other Calvinists would do well to read him. They might be surprised that he never once sounds like a Pelagian (and don’t let me mention the fact that he actually refutes Pelagius in his “Works”!).
Arminius then goes into the efficient, inward-moving, and external causes of this vocation to salvation:
“THE EFFICIENT CAUSE OF THIS VOCATION IS GOD THE FATHER IN THE SON. The Son himself, as appointed by the Father to be the Mediator and the King of his church, calls men by the Holy Spirit; as He is the Spirit of God given to the Mediator...but THIS VOCATION IS SO ADMINISTERED BY THE SPIRIT, THAT THE HOLY SPIRIT IS HIMSELF ITS EFFECTOR: for He appoints Bishops, sends forth teachers, endues them with gifts, grants them his assistance, and obtains authority for the word and bestows efficacy upon it (Hebrews iii,7; Acts xiii,2; xx,28; 1 Cor. xii,4,7,9,11; Heb. ii,4.)” (II:232).
Who brings about salvation? God the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. In other words, all three persons of the Trinity play a role in our salvation. With these words, how could anyone say that “Arminians attribute their salvation to themselves?” Do Calvinists not know that we, like they, believe the Scriptures when they teach that “it is not of yourselves, it is the gift of God; not of works, so that no man may boast” (Eph. 2:8-9)? I don’t see Arminius attributing salvation to man (“soli homo gloria”), but rather “Soli Deo Gloria,” the glory of God.
What is the inward-moving cause of our salvation?
“The Inly-moving Cause is THE GRACE, MERCY, AND ‘LOVE OF GOD OUR SAVIOUR TOWARD MAN;’ (Titus iii,4,5;) by which HE IS INCLINED TO RELIEVE THE MISERY OF SINFUL MAN, AND TO IMPART UNTO HIM ETERNAL FELICITY. (2 Tim. i,9,10.)” (II:232).
Once again, I don’t see man being given glory in this statement at all. Rather, it is God who “is inclined to relieve the misery of sinful man.” God is the one who is stirred to take man out of his tragic state; God is the one who, like the Good Samaritan, sees man in a state of helplessness and picks him up, cares for his wounds, and nurses him back to spiritual health (Luke 10:30-37). Arminius cites 2 Tim. 1:9-10, which states that God called us “not according to our works, but according to His own purpose and grace” (2 Tim. 1:9). How can Packer look at Classical Arminianism and falsely accuse Classic Arminians of attributing salvation to man?
I will continue to show Arminius’s thought regarding salvation in further posts. For now, let me end by using the words of Roger Olson:
“The common tendency is to impute to Arminianism every false belief...if the same method were used on Calvinism (as some Arminians have), Calvinists would howl in protest. We could argue that the Calvinist God, who predestines some people unconditionally to hell (EVEN IF ONLY BY DECREEING TO PASS OVER THEM IN ELECTION), is not a God of love but an arbitrary, capricious supreme being concerned only with displaying his own glory---even at the cost of the eternal destruction of souls he created. One principle that ought to be observed by all parties to this debate is BEFORE YOU DISAGREE MAKE SURE YOU UNDERSTAND. In other words, we must make sure that we can describe another’s theological position as he or she would describe it before we criticize or condemn. Another guiding principle should be DO NOT IMPUTE TO OTHERS BELIEFS YOU REGARD AS LOGICALLY ENTAILED BY THEIR BELIEFS BUT THAT THEY EXPLICITLY DENY” (Roger Olson, “Arminian Theology: Myths and Realities.” Downers Grove: InterVarsity Press, 2006, page 41).
Both Calvinists and Arminians would do well to heed Roger Olson’s words.
Throughout this series of “Getting the Story Straight,” I’ve demonstrated that J.I. Packer is grossly incorrect in his analysis of Arminianism---that is, Arminians are not Pelagian in their theology. Here today, I return to correct another false statement Packer makes about Arminians: that is, that Classical Arminians fail to attribute glory to God...that we attempt to give glory to man for our salvation.
In his Disputation XVI, titled “On the Vocation of Men to Salvation,” Arminius wrote the following:
“We define vocation, A GRACIOUS ACT OF GOD IN CHRIST, by which, through his word and Spirit, He calls forth sinful men, who are liable to condemnation and placed under the dominion of sin, from the condition of the animal life, and from the pollutions and corruptions of this world, (2 Tim. i,9; Matt. xi, 28; 1 Pet. ii,9,10; Gal. i,4; 2 Pet. ii, 20; Romans x, 13-15; 1 Pet. iii,19; Gen. vi,3,) unto ‘the fellowship of Jesus Christ,’ and of his kingdom and its benefits; that, being united unto Him as their Head, they may derive from Him life, sensation, motion, and a plenitude of every spiritual blessing, TO THE GLORY OF GOD and their own salvation. (1 Cor. i,9; Gal. ii,20; Ephes. i,3,6; 2 Thess. ii,13,14)” (Arminius, “Works,” II:231-232).
Arminius deems the call to salvation (vocation) as “a gracious act of God in Christ”; here, we find that it is God’s kindness that brings this about. And this is where Classical Arminians agree with Calvinists: there is nothing outside of God that dictates His actions. God does what He pleases...and He is pleased to call men and women to faith, to grant them life everlasting. Without this benevolence from God, no man or woman could, or would be, saved. Secondly, note that Arminius labels man as unworthy of this call to salvation: “He calls forth sinful men, who are liable to condemnation and placed under the dominion of sin.” The words “sinful men,” “liable to condemnation,” and “under the dominion of sin” tell us what man is and what he deserves---nothing short of Hell itself. So if any man or woman goes to Heaven, it is of nothing they deserve, but of what God has graciously given. This is “Soli Deo Gloria,” a praise to God because only God deserves praise for man’s blessings and eternal bliss with Christ.
Examine the passages Arminius notes at the end of the above quote. In 1 Corinthians 1:9, it is God “by whom you were called into the fellowship of His Son, Jesus Christ the Lord” (NKJV); in Galatians 2:20, it is Christ whom, as Paul says, “loved me and gave Himself for me.” In Ephesians 1:3, it is God the Father “who has blessed us with every spiritual blessing in the heavenly places in Christ.” And who gets the praise for salvation and all its benefits? “to the praise of the glory of HIS GRACE, by which HE made us accepted in the Beloved” (Eph. 1:6). And in 2 Thess. 2:13-14, it is God who “from the beginning chose you for salvation through sanctification by the Spirit and belief in the truth.” It is God who gets the glory for the salvation of man. Arminius’s references to these verses demonstrates his great desire to give God glory for his salvation. Once again, this is “soli deo Gloria,” for the glory of God alone. Contra Packer, Classical Arminians do not give themselves glory for their salvation. I don’t know if Packer has ever read Arminius, but he and all other Calvinists would do well to read him. They might be surprised that he never once sounds like a Pelagian (and don’t let me mention the fact that he actually refutes Pelagius in his “Works”!).
Arminius then goes into the efficient, inward-moving, and external causes of this vocation to salvation:
“THE EFFICIENT CAUSE OF THIS VOCATION IS GOD THE FATHER IN THE SON. The Son himself, as appointed by the Father to be the Mediator and the King of his church, calls men by the Holy Spirit; as He is the Spirit of God given to the Mediator...but THIS VOCATION IS SO ADMINISTERED BY THE SPIRIT, THAT THE HOLY SPIRIT IS HIMSELF ITS EFFECTOR: for He appoints Bishops, sends forth teachers, endues them with gifts, grants them his assistance, and obtains authority for the word and bestows efficacy upon it (Hebrews iii,7; Acts xiii,2; xx,28; 1 Cor. xii,4,7,9,11; Heb. ii,4.)” (II:232).
Who brings about salvation? God the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. In other words, all three persons of the Trinity play a role in our salvation. With these words, how could anyone say that “Arminians attribute their salvation to themselves?” Do Calvinists not know that we, like they, believe the Scriptures when they teach that “it is not of yourselves, it is the gift of God; not of works, so that no man may boast” (Eph. 2:8-9)? I don’t see Arminius attributing salvation to man (“soli homo gloria”), but rather “Soli Deo Gloria,” the glory of God.
What is the inward-moving cause of our salvation?
“The Inly-moving Cause is THE GRACE, MERCY, AND ‘LOVE OF GOD OUR SAVIOUR TOWARD MAN;’ (Titus iii,4,5;) by which HE IS INCLINED TO RELIEVE THE MISERY OF SINFUL MAN, AND TO IMPART UNTO HIM ETERNAL FELICITY. (2 Tim. i,9,10.)” (II:232).
Once again, I don’t see man being given glory in this statement at all. Rather, it is God who “is inclined to relieve the misery of sinful man.” God is the one who is stirred to take man out of his tragic state; God is the one who, like the Good Samaritan, sees man in a state of helplessness and picks him up, cares for his wounds, and nurses him back to spiritual health (Luke 10:30-37). Arminius cites 2 Tim. 1:9-10, which states that God called us “not according to our works, but according to His own purpose and grace” (2 Tim. 1:9). How can Packer look at Classical Arminianism and falsely accuse Classic Arminians of attributing salvation to man?
I will continue to show Arminius’s thought regarding salvation in further posts. For now, let me end by using the words of Roger Olson:
“The common tendency is to impute to Arminianism every false belief...if the same method were used on Calvinism (as some Arminians have), Calvinists would howl in protest. We could argue that the Calvinist God, who predestines some people unconditionally to hell (EVEN IF ONLY BY DECREEING TO PASS OVER THEM IN ELECTION), is not a God of love but an arbitrary, capricious supreme being concerned only with displaying his own glory---even at the cost of the eternal destruction of souls he created. One principle that ought to be observed by all parties to this debate is BEFORE YOU DISAGREE MAKE SURE YOU UNDERSTAND. In other words, we must make sure that we can describe another’s theological position as he or she would describe it before we criticize or condemn. Another guiding principle should be DO NOT IMPUTE TO OTHERS BELIEFS YOU REGARD AS LOGICALLY ENTAILED BY THEIR BELIEFS BUT THAT THEY EXPLICITLY DENY” (Roger Olson, “Arminian Theology: Myths and Realities.” Downers Grove: InterVarsity Press, 2006, page 41).
Both Calvinists and Arminians would do well to heed Roger Olson’s words.
Tuesday, August 10, 2010
Getting the Story Straight, Pt. IV: Keeping the Faith
“From these principles, the Arminians drew two deductions: first, that since the Bible regards faith as a free and responsible act, it cannot be caused by God, but is exercised independently of Him; second, that since the Bible regards faith as obligatory on the part of all who hear the gospel, ability to believe must be universal. Hence, they maintained, Scripture must be interpreted as teaching... (5.) It rests with believers to keep themselves in a state of grace by keeping up their faith; those who fail here fall away and are lost” (J.I. Packer, “Introduction” from “The Death of Death in the Death of Christ” by John Owen. London: Banner of Truth, 1959, pp. 3-4).
I think that of all the points Packer provides above regarding Arminians, I think number five is probably the most attacked tenet of Arminian theology. In this post, however, my goal is to show biblically why J.I. Packer should conform to Arminian theology and not make fun of it.
First, the concept of “keeping the faith” is vital to the life of the Apostle Paul. In 2 Timothy 4 he writes,
“I have fought the good fight, I have finished the race, I have KEPT THE FAITH” (2 Tim. 4:7, New King James Version).
Paul evidently felt the Holy Spirit move him to write the words “kept the faith” in his ending words to Timothy about his walk on earth and the reward of eternal life that awaited him. For Calvinists to look at this passage and deny that keeping the faith is important is problematic when one considers that these words, like all the words of Scripture, are “God-breathed” (theopneustos).
What about the words of Revelation 14?
“Here is the patience of the saints; here are those who KEEP the commandments of God and the FAITH OF JESUS” (NKJV).
Here we see that the saints “keep the commandments of God” and “keep the faith of Jesus.” Once again, the saints of the Revelation days will be those who hold onto their faith and endure much suffering, including imprisonment and death (Rev. 13:10). So, if keeping faith is important in the days of great tribulation, why wouldn’t keeping the faith be important now?
Packer’s words regarding tenet #5 above mention “it rests with believers to keep themselves in a state of grace by keeping up their faith...” Many Christians today often quote the verses of Romans 8:38-39 regarding the fact that “nothing shall be able to separate us from the love of God” and say, “See, nothing we do can take us out of our salvation.” However, what about the verse in Jude that states, “keep yourselves in the love of God” (Jude 21)? Why is it that Calvinists see Romans 8:38-39, but not Jude 21? And why is Romans 8:38-39 deemed more important to Calvinists than Jude 21? Shouldn’t “all” of Scripture be as equally valid and important? What about John 17, the famous High Priestly Prayer of Christ? Calvinists use John 17 to advance their theological agenda all the time...but what about John’s words in his epistles, which state that the godly person “purifies Himself” (1 John 3:3)? It seems then, that God provides preservation power, but I am commanded to persevere.
God is not responsible for “persevering” me in the faith; He has given me all I need to endure in the faith. If I don’t, then it’s my own fault.
What does it mean to “keep yourselves in the love of God”? John provides the answer in 1 John 5:
“For this is the love of God, that we keep His commandments. And His commandments are not burdensome” (1 John 5:3).
To “keep ourselves in the love of God” means “to keep His commandments.”
What these verses teach is that believers themselves must “work out [their] own salvation with fear and trembling” (Philippians 2:12).
This issue of “keeping oneself in a state of grace” applies to every Christian
believer. What are we to do with Paul’s words to the Galatians?
“You have become estranged from Christ, you who attempt to be justified by law; you have fallen from grace” (Galatians 5:4).
What about this issue of “falling from grace”? This phrase becomes significant only after we discover to WHOM Paul is speaking. We are given clues of the nature of the congregants throughout the Galatian letter itself:
“But now after you have known God, or rather are known by God, how is it that you turn again to the weak and beggarly elements, to which you desire again to be in bondage?” (Gal. 4:9)
The phrase “you have known God” and “are known by God” tell us all we need to know---that the congregation to which Paul writes is a believing congregation of Christians. Should the believers turn to the works of the law now and deny the grace they have been given, they will be labeled as “having fallen from grace.” Keeping oneself in a state of grace, therefore, involves keeping the faith. A simple syllogism will help:
#1. Salvation consists of grace and faith (Eph. 2:8)
#2 we have access by faith into the grace in which we stand (Rom. 5:2)
#3. To give up one’s faith is to deny oneself access to grace (based on Romans 5:2)
#4. Therefore, to fail to keep the faith is to fail to continue in grace
#5. Since salvation consists of grace and faith, to fail to keep faith and continue in God’s grace is to fall from salvation.
There are a ton of verses I could use to support the above syllogism. For example, I could use Acts 13:43 where Paul and Barnabas urged the congregation to “continue in the grace of God.” I could also use Hebrews 12:28, where the writer states that “let us have grace, by which we may serve God acceptably with reverence and godly fear” (Heb. 12:28). The word for “let us have” is “exomen,” which means “let us hold onto grace” or “let us keep grace” (laparola.net/greco). This then, refers to keeping oneself in a state of grace, contrary to what J.I. Packer claims.
Next in Packer’s attack is the phrase “keeping up their faith.” I’ve already shown above that Paul evaluates his own walk with God from beginning to end with the words “I have finished the race, I have KEPT THE FAITH” (2 Tim. 4:7). But there are other passages of Scripture as well that indicate to the reader that to continue believing is the key to obtaining final salvation. For example, let’s look at John’s words:
“These things I have written to you who believe in the name of the Son of God, that you may know that you have eternal life, and that you MAY CONTINUE TO BELIEVE in the name of the Son of God” (1 John 5:13, NKJV).
John is encouraging them to “remain believing.” Why is this, if one does not have to keep the faith? And this does not take into account Jesus’ words in the Gospels (Matthew 13, Mark 4, Luke 8) regarding the Parable of the Sower and the seed that fell on stony/rocky soil. If you compare the three Gospel passages just mentioned, you will find that Matthew 13:21 states that the seed “endures for a while”---which is in contrast to Luke 8:13, where the seed on rocky soil “believes for a while.” An interesting question to ask is, “Why do Matthew and Luke use ‘endure’ and ‘believe’ interchangeably in this parable? If endurance has nothing to do with “keeping the faith” (which goes against what Paul believed, 2 Tim. 4), why then, do the writers replace one word (“faith”) with another (“endurance”), or vice versa? Why is the Hebrew congregation told not to throw away their “full assurance of faith”, because they need endurance (Heb. 10:35-36)? What about the fact that “faith and perseverance of the saints” is a good phrase in Revelation (13:10; 14:12)? Not only do we find faith and perseverance linked in Revelation, but even the famous chapter of Romans 8 does the same: while it tells us of the hope of our salvation, it also states that we wait for our faith to become sight “with perseverance” (Rom. 8:25).
I could go on, but I will digress here. My point is this: with all the evidence I’ve provided, how can J.I. Packer be correct in his claims? He isn’t. Instead, he denies keeping ourselves in the grace of God (“continuing in the grace of God”) as well as keeping the faith (2 Tim. 4) and so forth. It seems to me that what Packer is really saying in all this is that a person doesn’t even need faith to be saved. This, however, contradicts so much of Scripture, particularly Hebrews 11:6. My final question to you is, “Do you believe Scripture or Packer?” The choice is yours.
I think that of all the points Packer provides above regarding Arminians, I think number five is probably the most attacked tenet of Arminian theology. In this post, however, my goal is to show biblically why J.I. Packer should conform to Arminian theology and not make fun of it.
First, the concept of “keeping the faith” is vital to the life of the Apostle Paul. In 2 Timothy 4 he writes,
“I have fought the good fight, I have finished the race, I have KEPT THE FAITH” (2 Tim. 4:7, New King James Version).
Paul evidently felt the Holy Spirit move him to write the words “kept the faith” in his ending words to Timothy about his walk on earth and the reward of eternal life that awaited him. For Calvinists to look at this passage and deny that keeping the faith is important is problematic when one considers that these words, like all the words of Scripture, are “God-breathed” (theopneustos).
What about the words of Revelation 14?
“Here is the patience of the saints; here are those who KEEP the commandments of God and the FAITH OF JESUS” (NKJV).
Here we see that the saints “keep the commandments of God” and “keep the faith of Jesus.” Once again, the saints of the Revelation days will be those who hold onto their faith and endure much suffering, including imprisonment and death (Rev. 13:10). So, if keeping faith is important in the days of great tribulation, why wouldn’t keeping the faith be important now?
Packer’s words regarding tenet #5 above mention “it rests with believers to keep themselves in a state of grace by keeping up their faith...” Many Christians today often quote the verses of Romans 8:38-39 regarding the fact that “nothing shall be able to separate us from the love of God” and say, “See, nothing we do can take us out of our salvation.” However, what about the verse in Jude that states, “keep yourselves in the love of God” (Jude 21)? Why is it that Calvinists see Romans 8:38-39, but not Jude 21? And why is Romans 8:38-39 deemed more important to Calvinists than Jude 21? Shouldn’t “all” of Scripture be as equally valid and important? What about John 17, the famous High Priestly Prayer of Christ? Calvinists use John 17 to advance their theological agenda all the time...but what about John’s words in his epistles, which state that the godly person “purifies Himself” (1 John 3:3)? It seems then, that God provides preservation power, but I am commanded to persevere.
God is not responsible for “persevering” me in the faith; He has given me all I need to endure in the faith. If I don’t, then it’s my own fault.
What does it mean to “keep yourselves in the love of God”? John provides the answer in 1 John 5:
“For this is the love of God, that we keep His commandments. And His commandments are not burdensome” (1 John 5:3).
To “keep ourselves in the love of God” means “to keep His commandments.”
What these verses teach is that believers themselves must “work out [their] own salvation with fear and trembling” (Philippians 2:12).
This issue of “keeping oneself in a state of grace” applies to every Christian
believer. What are we to do with Paul’s words to the Galatians?
“You have become estranged from Christ, you who attempt to be justified by law; you have fallen from grace” (Galatians 5:4).
What about this issue of “falling from grace”? This phrase becomes significant only after we discover to WHOM Paul is speaking. We are given clues of the nature of the congregants throughout the Galatian letter itself:
“But now after you have known God, or rather are known by God, how is it that you turn again to the weak and beggarly elements, to which you desire again to be in bondage?” (Gal. 4:9)
The phrase “you have known God” and “are known by God” tell us all we need to know---that the congregation to which Paul writes is a believing congregation of Christians. Should the believers turn to the works of the law now and deny the grace they have been given, they will be labeled as “having fallen from grace.” Keeping oneself in a state of grace, therefore, involves keeping the faith. A simple syllogism will help:
#1. Salvation consists of grace and faith (Eph. 2:8)
#2 we have access by faith into the grace in which we stand (Rom. 5:2)
#3. To give up one’s faith is to deny oneself access to grace (based on Romans 5:2)
#4. Therefore, to fail to keep the faith is to fail to continue in grace
#5. Since salvation consists of grace and faith, to fail to keep faith and continue in God’s grace is to fall from salvation.
There are a ton of verses I could use to support the above syllogism. For example, I could use Acts 13:43 where Paul and Barnabas urged the congregation to “continue in the grace of God.” I could also use Hebrews 12:28, where the writer states that “let us have grace, by which we may serve God acceptably with reverence and godly fear” (Heb. 12:28). The word for “let us have” is “exomen,” which means “let us hold onto grace” or “let us keep grace” (laparola.net/greco). This then, refers to keeping oneself in a state of grace, contrary to what J.I. Packer claims.
Next in Packer’s attack is the phrase “keeping up their faith.” I’ve already shown above that Paul evaluates his own walk with God from beginning to end with the words “I have finished the race, I have KEPT THE FAITH” (2 Tim. 4:7). But there are other passages of Scripture as well that indicate to the reader that to continue believing is the key to obtaining final salvation. For example, let’s look at John’s words:
“These things I have written to you who believe in the name of the Son of God, that you may know that you have eternal life, and that you MAY CONTINUE TO BELIEVE in the name of the Son of God” (1 John 5:13, NKJV).
John is encouraging them to “remain believing.” Why is this, if one does not have to keep the faith? And this does not take into account Jesus’ words in the Gospels (Matthew 13, Mark 4, Luke 8) regarding the Parable of the Sower and the seed that fell on stony/rocky soil. If you compare the three Gospel passages just mentioned, you will find that Matthew 13:21 states that the seed “endures for a while”---which is in contrast to Luke 8:13, where the seed on rocky soil “believes for a while.” An interesting question to ask is, “Why do Matthew and Luke use ‘endure’ and ‘believe’ interchangeably in this parable? If endurance has nothing to do with “keeping the faith” (which goes against what Paul believed, 2 Tim. 4), why then, do the writers replace one word (“faith”) with another (“endurance”), or vice versa? Why is the Hebrew congregation told not to throw away their “full assurance of faith”, because they need endurance (Heb. 10:35-36)? What about the fact that “faith and perseverance of the saints” is a good phrase in Revelation (13:10; 14:12)? Not only do we find faith and perseverance linked in Revelation, but even the famous chapter of Romans 8 does the same: while it tells us of the hope of our salvation, it also states that we wait for our faith to become sight “with perseverance” (Rom. 8:25).
I could go on, but I will digress here. My point is this: with all the evidence I’ve provided, how can J.I. Packer be correct in his claims? He isn’t. Instead, he denies keeping ourselves in the grace of God (“continuing in the grace of God”) as well as keeping the faith (2 Tim. 4) and so forth. It seems to me that what Packer is really saying in all this is that a person doesn’t even need faith to be saved. This, however, contradicts so much of Scripture, particularly Hebrews 11:6. My final question to you is, “Do you believe Scripture or Packer?” The choice is yours.
Monday, August 9, 2010
Getting the Story Straight, Pt. III: Total Depravity
“...from these principles, the Arminians drew two deductions; first, that since the Bible regards faith as a free and responsible act, it cannot be caused by God, but is exercised independently of Him; second, that since the Bible regards faith as obligatory on the part of all who hear the gospel, ability to believe must be universal. Hence they maintained, Scripture must be interpreted as teaching the following positions: (1.) Man is never so completely corrupted by sin that he cannot savingly believe the gospel when it is put before him...” (J.I. Packer, “Introduction” in “The Death of Death in the Death of Christ” by John Owen. London: Banner of Truth, 1959, pp. 3-4)
For the last two posts, I’ve been combating J.I. Packer’s ideas regarding Classical Arminian theology. Today, I’m back to do this once again---this time, through discussion of the biblical notion of depravity.
Packer claims that Arminians believe that man is not completely corrupted by sin; however, this is not true at all. For my defense, I provide the words of Arminius:
“...having turned away from the light of his own mind and his Chief Good, which is God, or, at least, having turned towards that Chief Good not in the manner in which he ought to have done, and besides having turned in mind and heart towards an inferior good, he transgressed the command given to him for life. By this foul deed, he precipitated himself from that noble and elevated condition into a state of the deepest infelicity, which is UNDER THE DOMINION OF SIN...in this state, the free will of man towards the True Good is not only WOUNDED, MAIMED, INFIRM, BENT, AND WEAKENED; BUT IT IS ALSO IMPRISONED, DESTROYED, AND LOST; AND ITS POWERS ARE NOT ONLY DEBILITATED AND USELESS UNLESS THEY BE ASSISTED BY GRACE, BUT IT HAS NO POWERS WHATEVER EXCEPT SUCH AS ARE EXCITED BY DIVINE GRACE: for Christ has said, ‘Without me ye can do nothing’” (James Arminius, “Works,” II:192).
Adam’s sin was imputed to all of the human race, in such a way that our will to choose the good is imprisoned to sin and evil...and, without grace, we would never choose the good, never accept Christ, never submit to His Lordship. Arminius even went so far as to say, “It [free will of man] has no powers whatever except such as are excited by divine grace.” It is the grace of God that “makes alive” the will, not man himself.
Arminius goes into greater detail regarding the depravity of man. He starts with the mind of man:
“The mind of man, in this state, is dark, destitute of the saving knowledge of God, and, according to the Apostle, incapable of those things which belong to the Spirit of God: For ‘the animal man has no perception of the things of the Spirit of God;’ (1 Cor. ii, 14;) in which passage man is called ‘animal,’ not from the animal body, but from ‘anima,’ the soul itself, which is the most noble part of man, but which is so encompassed about with the clouds of ignorance, as to be distinguished by the epithets of ‘vain’ and ‘foolish’; and men themselves, thus darkened in their minds, are denominated ‘mad’ or foolish, ‘fools,’ and even ‘darkness’ itself. (Rom. I, 21, 22; Ephes. iv, 17, 18; Titus iii, 3; Ephes. v, 8) This is true, not only when...it [the mind] is preparing to form conclusions by the understanding; BUT LIKEWISE WHEN, BY SIMPLE APPREHENSION, IT WOULD RECEIVE THE TRUTH OF THE GOSPEL EXTERNALLY OFFERED TO IT: for the human mind judges that to be ‘foolishness’ which is the most excellent ‘Wisdom’ of God (1 Cor. i,18,24)” (Arminius, “Works,” II:193).
Man is so depraved that, not only is his thinking about ordinary life skewed (for instance, man cannot escape his presuppositions), but he can’t even receive the Gospel naturally on his own. To receive the Gospel, man must be granted grace by the Spirit of Grace Himself. And why? because of 1 Corinthians 1, a passage Arminius quotes as to say that “the human mind judges that to be ‘foolishness’ which is the most excellent ‘Wisdom’ of God.” In addition, Arminius cites other passages in his quote, such as Romans 1, Ephesians 4 and 5, etc. to show that he believes man is naturally born with a darkened mind, a mind that desperately needs to be illuminated and enlightened by the Lord Himself if the son or daughter of Adam and Eve will ever come to faith.
Next, the affections and heart are affected by sin:
“it [the heart] hates and has an aversion to that which is truly good and pleasing to God; but it loves and pursues what is evil. The Apostle was unable to afford a more luminous description of this perverseness, than he has given in the following words: ‘The carnal mind is enmity against God: for it is not subject to the law of God, neither indeed can be. So then they that are in the flesh cannot please God’ (Rom. viii, 7). For this reason, the human heart itself is very often called deceitful and perverse, uncircumcised, hard and stony;’(Jer. xiii, 10; xvii,9; Ezek. xxxvi, 26:) Its imagination is said to be ‘only evil from his very youth;’ (Gen. vi, 5; viii, 21;) and ‘out of the heart proceed evil thoughts, murders, adulteries, &c. (Matt. xv,19.)” (Works II:193).
Arminius quotes from Romans 8:7 to show that those who are not saved cannot please God. He also shows that the heart is deceitful and wicked, and that man’s every thought is evil, according to the words of the Lord Himself in Genesis 6. Arminius’ work here shows us that he very much held to Reformed theology, as biblical a view on depravity (at least) as any follower of John Calvin.
J.I. Packer notes in his quote above that Arminians don’t believe in the total inability of man. Well, let’s try out Arminius’ words on the helplessness of the human condition:
“Exactly correspondent to this darkness of the mind, and perverseness of the heart, is THE UTTER WEAKNESS OF ALL THE POWERS TO PERFORM THAT WHICH IS TRULY GOOD...the subjoined sayings of Christ serve to describe this impotence: ‘A corrupt tree cannot bring forth good fruit.’ (Matt. vii, 18.) ‘How can ye, being evil, speak good things?’ (xii, 34.) The following relates to the good which is properly prescribed in the Gospel: ‘No man can come to me, except the Father draw him:’ (John vi, 44:)...the Apostle says, ‘when we were in the flesh, the motions of sin wrought in us,’ or flourished energetically (Rom. vii, 5.) To the same purpose are all those passages in which the man existing in this state is said to be under the power of sin and Satan, reduced to the condition of a slave, and ‘taken captive by the Devil.’ (Rom. vi,20; 2 Tim.ii,26.)” (“Works,” II:194).
In Arminius’s description of human inability, he notes the favorite verse used by Calvinists in their assessment of depravity: John 6:44. Yes, as surprising as it may seem, Arminians DO believe in the depravity of man!!!
What I’ve provided here should be enough. The point of Arminius citations here is to say to Packer and the Calvinist clan that we, like them, believe in human depravity and human inability. We do not argue some “semi-Pelagian” or “Pelagian” notion of man where the only thing man lost was his knowledge in the Garden of Eden; rather, we argue that man lost his power to will the spiritual Good that day...and that, without God’s awakening, enabling, and sustaining grace, man cannot place himself, and will not be placed, on the path that leads to glory. In man’s natural state, he is drowning in the ocean of life, and desperately needs the Lord Jesus Christ to throw him a lifeline. Without it, man only has the second death to look forward to.
For the last two posts, I’ve been combating J.I. Packer’s ideas regarding Classical Arminian theology. Today, I’m back to do this once again---this time, through discussion of the biblical notion of depravity.
Packer claims that Arminians believe that man is not completely corrupted by sin; however, this is not true at all. For my defense, I provide the words of Arminius:
“...having turned away from the light of his own mind and his Chief Good, which is God, or, at least, having turned towards that Chief Good not in the manner in which he ought to have done, and besides having turned in mind and heart towards an inferior good, he transgressed the command given to him for life. By this foul deed, he precipitated himself from that noble and elevated condition into a state of the deepest infelicity, which is UNDER THE DOMINION OF SIN...in this state, the free will of man towards the True Good is not only WOUNDED, MAIMED, INFIRM, BENT, AND WEAKENED; BUT IT IS ALSO IMPRISONED, DESTROYED, AND LOST; AND ITS POWERS ARE NOT ONLY DEBILITATED AND USELESS UNLESS THEY BE ASSISTED BY GRACE, BUT IT HAS NO POWERS WHATEVER EXCEPT SUCH AS ARE EXCITED BY DIVINE GRACE: for Christ has said, ‘Without me ye can do nothing’” (James Arminius, “Works,” II:192).
Adam’s sin was imputed to all of the human race, in such a way that our will to choose the good is imprisoned to sin and evil...and, without grace, we would never choose the good, never accept Christ, never submit to His Lordship. Arminius even went so far as to say, “It [free will of man] has no powers whatever except such as are excited by divine grace.” It is the grace of God that “makes alive” the will, not man himself.
Arminius goes into greater detail regarding the depravity of man. He starts with the mind of man:
“The mind of man, in this state, is dark, destitute of the saving knowledge of God, and, according to the Apostle, incapable of those things which belong to the Spirit of God: For ‘the animal man has no perception of the things of the Spirit of God;’ (1 Cor. ii, 14;) in which passage man is called ‘animal,’ not from the animal body, but from ‘anima,’ the soul itself, which is the most noble part of man, but which is so encompassed about with the clouds of ignorance, as to be distinguished by the epithets of ‘vain’ and ‘foolish’; and men themselves, thus darkened in their minds, are denominated ‘mad’ or foolish, ‘fools,’ and even ‘darkness’ itself. (Rom. I, 21, 22; Ephes. iv, 17, 18; Titus iii, 3; Ephes. v, 8) This is true, not only when...it [the mind] is preparing to form conclusions by the understanding; BUT LIKEWISE WHEN, BY SIMPLE APPREHENSION, IT WOULD RECEIVE THE TRUTH OF THE GOSPEL EXTERNALLY OFFERED TO IT: for the human mind judges that to be ‘foolishness’ which is the most excellent ‘Wisdom’ of God (1 Cor. i,18,24)” (Arminius, “Works,” II:193).
Man is so depraved that, not only is his thinking about ordinary life skewed (for instance, man cannot escape his presuppositions), but he can’t even receive the Gospel naturally on his own. To receive the Gospel, man must be granted grace by the Spirit of Grace Himself. And why? because of 1 Corinthians 1, a passage Arminius quotes as to say that “the human mind judges that to be ‘foolishness’ which is the most excellent ‘Wisdom’ of God.” In addition, Arminius cites other passages in his quote, such as Romans 1, Ephesians 4 and 5, etc. to show that he believes man is naturally born with a darkened mind, a mind that desperately needs to be illuminated and enlightened by the Lord Himself if the son or daughter of Adam and Eve will ever come to faith.
Next, the affections and heart are affected by sin:
“it [the heart] hates and has an aversion to that which is truly good and pleasing to God; but it loves and pursues what is evil. The Apostle was unable to afford a more luminous description of this perverseness, than he has given in the following words: ‘The carnal mind is enmity against God: for it is not subject to the law of God, neither indeed can be. So then they that are in the flesh cannot please God’ (Rom. viii, 7). For this reason, the human heart itself is very often called deceitful and perverse, uncircumcised, hard and stony;’(Jer. xiii, 10; xvii,9; Ezek. xxxvi, 26:) Its imagination is said to be ‘only evil from his very youth;’ (Gen. vi, 5; viii, 21;) and ‘out of the heart proceed evil thoughts, murders, adulteries, &c. (Matt. xv,19.)” (Works II:193).
Arminius quotes from Romans 8:7 to show that those who are not saved cannot please God. He also shows that the heart is deceitful and wicked, and that man’s every thought is evil, according to the words of the Lord Himself in Genesis 6. Arminius’ work here shows us that he very much held to Reformed theology, as biblical a view on depravity (at least) as any follower of John Calvin.
J.I. Packer notes in his quote above that Arminians don’t believe in the total inability of man. Well, let’s try out Arminius’ words on the helplessness of the human condition:
“Exactly correspondent to this darkness of the mind, and perverseness of the heart, is THE UTTER WEAKNESS OF ALL THE POWERS TO PERFORM THAT WHICH IS TRULY GOOD...the subjoined sayings of Christ serve to describe this impotence: ‘A corrupt tree cannot bring forth good fruit.’ (Matt. vii, 18.) ‘How can ye, being evil, speak good things?’ (xii, 34.) The following relates to the good which is properly prescribed in the Gospel: ‘No man can come to me, except the Father draw him:’ (John vi, 44:)...the Apostle says, ‘when we were in the flesh, the motions of sin wrought in us,’ or flourished energetically (Rom. vii, 5.) To the same purpose are all those passages in which the man existing in this state is said to be under the power of sin and Satan, reduced to the condition of a slave, and ‘taken captive by the Devil.’ (Rom. vi,20; 2 Tim.ii,26.)” (“Works,” II:194).
In Arminius’s description of human inability, he notes the favorite verse used by Calvinists in their assessment of depravity: John 6:44. Yes, as surprising as it may seem, Arminians DO believe in the depravity of man!!!
What I’ve provided here should be enough. The point of Arminius citations here is to say to Packer and the Calvinist clan that we, like them, believe in human depravity and human inability. We do not argue some “semi-Pelagian” or “Pelagian” notion of man where the only thing man lost was his knowledge in the Garden of Eden; rather, we argue that man lost his power to will the spiritual Good that day...and that, without God’s awakening, enabling, and sustaining grace, man cannot place himself, and will not be placed, on the path that leads to glory. In man’s natural state, he is drowning in the ocean of life, and desperately needs the Lord Jesus Christ to throw him a lifeline. Without it, man only has the second death to look forward to.
Friday, August 6, 2010
Getting the Story Straight, Pt. I
“J.I. Packer, in analyzing the system of thought embodied in the Remonstrance, observes:
‘The theology which it contained (known to history as Arminianism) stemmed from two philosophical principles: first, that divine sovereignty is not compatible with human freedom, nor therefore with human responsibility; second, that ability limits obligation...from these principles, the Arminians drew two deductions: first, that since the Bible regards faith as a free and responsible act, IT CANNOT BE CAUSED BY GOD, BUT IS EXERCISED INDEPENDENTLY OF HIM; second, that since the Bible regards faith as obligatory on the part of all who hear the gospel, ABILITY TO BELIEVE MUST BE UNIVERSAL. Hence, they maintained, Scripture must be interpreted as teaching the following positions: (1.) Man is never so completely corrupted by sin that he cannot savingly believe the gospel when it is put before him, nor (2.) is he ever so completely controlled by God that he cannot reject it. (3.) God’s election of those who shall be saved is prompted by His foreseeing that they will of their own accord believe. (4.) Christ’s death did not ensure the salvation of anyone, for it did not secure the gift of faith to anyone (THERE IS NO SUCH GIFT); what it did was rather to create a possibility of salvation for everyone if they believe. (5.) It rests with believers to keep themselves in a state of grace by keeping up their faith; those who fail here fall away and are lost. Thus, Arminianism made man’s salvation depend ultimately on man himself, saving faith being viewed throughout as man’s own work and, because his own, not God’s in him” (J.I. Packer, “Introductory Essay,” from “The Death of Death in the Death of Christ” by John Owen. London: Banner of Truth, 1959, pp. 3-4. Quoted by David Steele, Curtis Thomas, and S. Lance Quinn in “The Five Points of Calvinism: Defined, Defended, and Documented, Second Edition.” Phillipsburg: P&R Publishing, 2004, pp. 2-3).
I know people who, on a daily basis, can never recount events as they happen. Usually, they always have an interpretation of the events that seems to “embellish” the truth, just a bit (we call it “lying”). I don’t know why they choose to lie instead of being honest and telling the truth; but I do know that “truth will win out in the end.” No matter how seemingly perfect the lie, the truth will always come out---whether for better or worse.
My disgust with dishonesty spills over into theology whenever I sit down and read the work of a theologian (usually someone who holds to a dogmatic theology) who cannot accurately espouse the other views. Take Molinism, for example: I attended Dr. Ken Keathley’s class this summer, plus read Molina’s “Concordia,” “Salvation and Sovereignty: A Molinist Approach” (Ken Keathley’s book), William Lane Craig’s “The Only Wise God,” Kirk R. MacGregor’s “A Molinist-Anabaptist Systematic Theology,” and Thomas Flint’s “Divine Providence: A Molinist Account.” I did these things not to tell you what I’ve read and brag about it; I attended Dr. Keathley’s class and read the five Molinist works because I desire to espouse Molinist theology correctly here at the Center for Theological Studies. No one is making me agree that Molinism (or even Calvinism) is right. I think both theologies have irreconcilable problems...but my beliefs about the two theological systems will not keep me from espousing them correctly. I may disagree, but I will disagree because of the truth of the systems and not because of a misinterpretation regarding them.
J.I. Packer doesn’t get the story straight here in his quote above regarding Arminianism. First, let’s make it clear that Classical Arminians see divine sovereignty and human responsibility as reconcilable concepts. We do not approach these two theological concepts in Scripture and argue that there is no way to make sense of their working together. We hold to a firm view of Romans 9 when we argue that God, in His Sovereignty, established faith as the condition for salvation; and for all who believe, in that very moment, they have become heirs of eternal life. We believe that God’s sovereignty is the foundation for human responsibility. Regarding Packer’s next claim, that we believe that “ability limits obligation,” I think he meant to say that Arminians believe “INABILITY limits obligation.” I’m simply espousing Packer’s beliefs regarding Classical Arminianism.
Regarding his claim though, Packer is right on this one. Classical Arminians believe that if God does not enable every person to believe in Him, then God is the one responsible. We hold firmly to John 3:18 when it says that “he that believes not is condemned already” because he has not believed on the name of the Son of God. If God will condemn a sinner for unbelief, then he or she must be enabled by God to believe. Contra Packer, our view of salvation can be found in the Scriptures.
Packer then goes into what he calls “two Arminian deductions.” The first is that we believe faith, to be genuine, cannot be caused by God “but is exercised independently of Him.” Unfortunately, Packer is wrong once more. Faith itself, as the Scriptures tell us, is the gift of God (Eph. 2:8-9). As such, faith cannot be exercised “independent” of God. Now, if Packer means that God does not “cause” some to believe and leaves others to their damnation, we answer in the affirmative. We do not believe that God picks certain individuals to be saved and damns others. We believe that faith is dispensed by the Spirit to every individual whenever the Word of God is preached. Paul states this when he tells the Romans, “So faith comes from what is heard, and what is heard comes through the message about Christ” (Rom. 10:17, HCSB). And the importance of the Word in bringing someone to faith is emphasized when Paul asks, “But how can they call on Him in whom they have not heard? And HOW CAN THEY BELIEVE WITHOUT HEARING ABOUT HIM?” (Rom. 10:14) Whenever someone hears the message of Christ, the Spirit of grace dispenses the grace and faith needed to believe. Yes, we too, like the Calvinist, believe that God must draw someone in order to bring about confession and belief (John 6:44). Where we differ from J.I. Packer and other Calvinists is that, unlike them, we believe that the Spirit influences the unbeliever to profess Christ, not “drag” him up the aisle to force a confession out of him. As a result, the ability to believe is given by the Spirit via special revelation, not general revelation.
I will tackle the five conclusions that Packer lists in upcoming posts.
‘The theology which it contained (known to history as Arminianism) stemmed from two philosophical principles: first, that divine sovereignty is not compatible with human freedom, nor therefore with human responsibility; second, that ability limits obligation...from these principles, the Arminians drew two deductions: first, that since the Bible regards faith as a free and responsible act, IT CANNOT BE CAUSED BY GOD, BUT IS EXERCISED INDEPENDENTLY OF HIM; second, that since the Bible regards faith as obligatory on the part of all who hear the gospel, ABILITY TO BELIEVE MUST BE UNIVERSAL. Hence, they maintained, Scripture must be interpreted as teaching the following positions: (1.) Man is never so completely corrupted by sin that he cannot savingly believe the gospel when it is put before him, nor (2.) is he ever so completely controlled by God that he cannot reject it. (3.) God’s election of those who shall be saved is prompted by His foreseeing that they will of their own accord believe. (4.) Christ’s death did not ensure the salvation of anyone, for it did not secure the gift of faith to anyone (THERE IS NO SUCH GIFT); what it did was rather to create a possibility of salvation for everyone if they believe. (5.) It rests with believers to keep themselves in a state of grace by keeping up their faith; those who fail here fall away and are lost. Thus, Arminianism made man’s salvation depend ultimately on man himself, saving faith being viewed throughout as man’s own work and, because his own, not God’s in him” (J.I. Packer, “Introductory Essay,” from “The Death of Death in the Death of Christ” by John Owen. London: Banner of Truth, 1959, pp. 3-4. Quoted by David Steele, Curtis Thomas, and S. Lance Quinn in “The Five Points of Calvinism: Defined, Defended, and Documented, Second Edition.” Phillipsburg: P&R Publishing, 2004, pp. 2-3).
I know people who, on a daily basis, can never recount events as they happen. Usually, they always have an interpretation of the events that seems to “embellish” the truth, just a bit (we call it “lying”). I don’t know why they choose to lie instead of being honest and telling the truth; but I do know that “truth will win out in the end.” No matter how seemingly perfect the lie, the truth will always come out---whether for better or worse.
My disgust with dishonesty spills over into theology whenever I sit down and read the work of a theologian (usually someone who holds to a dogmatic theology) who cannot accurately espouse the other views. Take Molinism, for example: I attended Dr. Ken Keathley’s class this summer, plus read Molina’s “Concordia,” “Salvation and Sovereignty: A Molinist Approach” (Ken Keathley’s book), William Lane Craig’s “The Only Wise God,” Kirk R. MacGregor’s “A Molinist-Anabaptist Systematic Theology,” and Thomas Flint’s “Divine Providence: A Molinist Account.” I did these things not to tell you what I’ve read and brag about it; I attended Dr. Keathley’s class and read the five Molinist works because I desire to espouse Molinist theology correctly here at the Center for Theological Studies. No one is making me agree that Molinism (or even Calvinism) is right. I think both theologies have irreconcilable problems...but my beliefs about the two theological systems will not keep me from espousing them correctly. I may disagree, but I will disagree because of the truth of the systems and not because of a misinterpretation regarding them.
J.I. Packer doesn’t get the story straight here in his quote above regarding Arminianism. First, let’s make it clear that Classical Arminians see divine sovereignty and human responsibility as reconcilable concepts. We do not approach these two theological concepts in Scripture and argue that there is no way to make sense of their working together. We hold to a firm view of Romans 9 when we argue that God, in His Sovereignty, established faith as the condition for salvation; and for all who believe, in that very moment, they have become heirs of eternal life. We believe that God’s sovereignty is the foundation for human responsibility. Regarding Packer’s next claim, that we believe that “ability limits obligation,” I think he meant to say that Arminians believe “INABILITY limits obligation.” I’m simply espousing Packer’s beliefs regarding Classical Arminianism.
Regarding his claim though, Packer is right on this one. Classical Arminians believe that if God does not enable every person to believe in Him, then God is the one responsible. We hold firmly to John 3:18 when it says that “he that believes not is condemned already” because he has not believed on the name of the Son of God. If God will condemn a sinner for unbelief, then he or she must be enabled by God to believe. Contra Packer, our view of salvation can be found in the Scriptures.
Packer then goes into what he calls “two Arminian deductions.” The first is that we believe faith, to be genuine, cannot be caused by God “but is exercised independently of Him.” Unfortunately, Packer is wrong once more. Faith itself, as the Scriptures tell us, is the gift of God (Eph. 2:8-9). As such, faith cannot be exercised “independent” of God. Now, if Packer means that God does not “cause” some to believe and leaves others to their damnation, we answer in the affirmative. We do not believe that God picks certain individuals to be saved and damns others. We believe that faith is dispensed by the Spirit to every individual whenever the Word of God is preached. Paul states this when he tells the Romans, “So faith comes from what is heard, and what is heard comes through the message about Christ” (Rom. 10:17, HCSB). And the importance of the Word in bringing someone to faith is emphasized when Paul asks, “But how can they call on Him in whom they have not heard? And HOW CAN THEY BELIEVE WITHOUT HEARING ABOUT HIM?” (Rom. 10:14) Whenever someone hears the message of Christ, the Spirit of grace dispenses the grace and faith needed to believe. Yes, we too, like the Calvinist, believe that God must draw someone in order to bring about confession and belief (John 6:44). Where we differ from J.I. Packer and other Calvinists is that, unlike them, we believe that the Spirit influences the unbeliever to profess Christ, not “drag” him up the aisle to force a confession out of him. As a result, the ability to believe is given by the Spirit via special revelation, not general revelation.
I will tackle the five conclusions that Packer lists in upcoming posts.
Tuesday, July 6, 2010
Limiting the Atonement, Part I: The Bible Speaks
“Spurgeon’s comments as to whether it is the Calvinists or the Arminians who limit the Atonement, are to the point. ‘We are often told that we limit the atonement of Christ, because we say that Christ has not made a satisfaction for all men, or all men would be saved. Now, our reply to this is, that, on the other hand, our opponents limit it: we do not. The Arminians say, Christ died for all men. Ask them what they mean by it. Did Christ die so as to secure the salvation of all men? They say, ‘No, certainly not.’ WE ASK THEM THE NEXT QUESTION---DID CHRIST DIE SO AS TO SECURE THE SALVATION OF ANY MAN IN PARTICULAR? THEY ANSWER, ‘NO. CHRIST HAS DIED THAT ANY MAN MAY BE SAVED IF’---AND THEN FOLLOW CERTAIN CONDITIONS OF SALVATION. NOW, WHO IS IT THAT LIMITS THE DEATH OF CHRIST? WHY, YOU. You say that Christ did not die so as infallibly to secure the salvation of anybody. We beg your pardon, when you say we limit Christ’s death; we say, ‘No, my dear sir, it is you that do it.’ We say Christ so died that he infallibly secured the salvation of a multitude that no man can number, who through Christ’s death not only may be saved, but are saved and cannot by any possibility run the hazard of being anything but saved. You are welcome to your atonement: you may keep it. We will never renounce ours for the sake of it” [Quoted from James I. Packer, ‘Introductory Essay,’ in “The Death of Death in the Death of Christ,” by John Owen (London: Banner of Truth, 1959), page 14. Quoted in “The Five Points of Calvinism: Defined, Defended, and Documented, Second Edition” by David N. Steele, Curtis C. Thomas, and S. Lance Quinn. Phillipsburg: P&R Publishing, 2004, page 41).
Arminians have been accused of many things throughout church history. They have been accused of being “man-centered” in their theology, Pelagian, heretical, false teachers, etc...but I never thought I’d see the day when Arminians would be accused of limiting the atonement. I read this argument somewhere several months (maybe a year) ago, but didn’t pay the argument much attention. I’ve learned that sometimes, in the Calvinism-Arminianism debate, one has to “shut off” one’s eyes from some arguments. Some arguments are good and worthwhile to debate; but others are just illogical arguments posed by Calvinists in order to “prop” up their system.
I decided to take up the Charles Spurgeon quote above because, first, let me make it known that EVERYONE I know pretty much adores the great Baptist preacher Charles Haddon Spurgeon. Here at Southeastern, Spurgeon is hailed as one of the greatest preachers of all time. I believe the man did great things in his time, and I praise God that Baptists have such a historical figure to look to for pride in their religious heritage.
At the same time, however, this post will attack and criticize Spurgeon’s quote above. Why? because Spurgeon’s quote is a logical attack with little Scriptural backing.
First, he states, “our reply to this is, that, on the other hand, OUR OPPONENTS LIMIT IT: WE DO NOT” (41).
Calvinists hold to limited atonement; first off, note that it is called “limited” for a reason---because it “limits” the atonement to a select group of the mass of humanity. According to Calvinism, God only died for “the elect,” those individuals He handpicked for salvation. The fact that Spurgeon would deny how the Calvinist view of the atonement “limits” it is appalling indeed.
Next, Spurgeon calls the Arminians on “consistency,” which is a good word to use: “Did Christ die so as to secure the salvation of any man in particular? They answer, ‘No.’ THEY ARE OBLIGED TO ADMIT THIS, IF THEY ARE CONSISTENT” (41).
I’m glad Spurgeon used the word “consistent” and stated that Arminians are “obliged” to answer in the negative regarding secured salvation. In response, I would respond, “Okay, Mr. Spurgeon; so if Arminians are to be consistent in their theology, let’s question Calvinists.” Then, I would ask the question, “How are Calvinists consistent in their theology if they hold to Jesus dying for everyone (“unlimited atonement”), yet insist that God handpicks certain individuals for salvation and bypasses others (“unconditional election”)? How can God offer Himself on behalf of every single person in the world, if He only draws a few through “irresistible grace”?
Chances are, Charles Spurgeon, one of the greatest preachers of Baptist history, probably could not answer this one. He often felt as if the doctrine of supralapsarianism was a harsh one---yet, it is consistent, if God only handpicks a few people to be saved (for where will the rest of humanity go but to Hell?). Spurgeon said the following about God unconditionally reprobating a mass of humanity to Hell:
“Do you believe that God created man and arbitrarily, sovereignly---it is the same thing---CREATED THAT MAN, WITH NO OTHER INTENTION, THAN THAT OF DAMNING HIM? Made him, and yet, for no other reason than that of destroying him forever? Well, if you can believe it, I PITY YOU, THAT IS ALL I CAN SAY: YOU DESERVE PITY, THAT YOU SHOULD THINK SO MEANLY OF GOD, WHOSE MERCY ENDURETH FOREVER” (Charles Spurgeon, “Jacob and Esau,” page 118; quoted by Ken Keathley, “Salvation and Sovereignty: A Molinist Approach.” Nashville: Broadman and Holman, 2010, page 145).
Spurgeon admits via the quote above that he is infralapsarian; however, his infralapsarianism is itself inconsistent:
“To genuinely embrace the concept of permission would require the infralapsarian to abandon some of the key tenets of Reformed theology. Berkhof recognized this when he warned, ‘Infralapsarianism really wants to explain reprobation as an act of God’s justice. It is inclined to deny either explicitly or implicitly that it is an act of the mere good pleasure of God. THIS REALLY MAKES THE DECREE OF REPROBATION A CONDITIONAL DECREE AND LEADS INTO THE ARMINIAN FOLD.’ INFRALAPSARIANS HAVE A CHOICE. IF THE DECREE TO REPROBATION IS CONDITIONAL, THEN IT IS NOT ACCORDING TO GOD’S MERE GOOD PLEASURE. IF IT IS UNCONDITIONAL, THEN IT IS NOT ACCORDING TO GOD’S PERMISSION. Infralapsarianism wants to teach that God damns the reprobate in response to their sins, but THIS WOULD ABANDON THE CLASSIC REFORMED VIEW OF GOD’S SOVEREIGNTY, WHICH IS WHY CALVIN REJECTED THE CONCEPT OF PERMISSION OUT OF HAND” (Ken Keathley, “Salvation and Sovereignty: A Molinist Approach.” Nashville: Broadman and Holman, 2010, page 146).
If Charles Spurgeon was to be consistent, he needed to hold on to supralapsarianism (the unconditional reprobation of the damned), which is something he could not do. Funny though, wasn’t he trying to “school” the Arminian camp about being “consistent”? But how could he hold on to the “conditional” reprobation of the damned while arguing “unconditional” election of the saved? Sounds a bit inconsistent to me...
What about Spurgeon’s attack on Arminianism itself? I will get into his attack on Arminianism’s “limited” atonement in my next post...
Arminians have been accused of many things throughout church history. They have been accused of being “man-centered” in their theology, Pelagian, heretical, false teachers, etc...but I never thought I’d see the day when Arminians would be accused of limiting the atonement. I read this argument somewhere several months (maybe a year) ago, but didn’t pay the argument much attention. I’ve learned that sometimes, in the Calvinism-Arminianism debate, one has to “shut off” one’s eyes from some arguments. Some arguments are good and worthwhile to debate; but others are just illogical arguments posed by Calvinists in order to “prop” up their system.
I decided to take up the Charles Spurgeon quote above because, first, let me make it known that EVERYONE I know pretty much adores the great Baptist preacher Charles Haddon Spurgeon. Here at Southeastern, Spurgeon is hailed as one of the greatest preachers of all time. I believe the man did great things in his time, and I praise God that Baptists have such a historical figure to look to for pride in their religious heritage.
At the same time, however, this post will attack and criticize Spurgeon’s quote above. Why? because Spurgeon’s quote is a logical attack with little Scriptural backing.
First, he states, “our reply to this is, that, on the other hand, OUR OPPONENTS LIMIT IT: WE DO NOT” (41).
Calvinists hold to limited atonement; first off, note that it is called “limited” for a reason---because it “limits” the atonement to a select group of the mass of humanity. According to Calvinism, God only died for “the elect,” those individuals He handpicked for salvation. The fact that Spurgeon would deny how the Calvinist view of the atonement “limits” it is appalling indeed.
Next, Spurgeon calls the Arminians on “consistency,” which is a good word to use: “Did Christ die so as to secure the salvation of any man in particular? They answer, ‘No.’ THEY ARE OBLIGED TO ADMIT THIS, IF THEY ARE CONSISTENT” (41).
I’m glad Spurgeon used the word “consistent” and stated that Arminians are “obliged” to answer in the negative regarding secured salvation. In response, I would respond, “Okay, Mr. Spurgeon; so if Arminians are to be consistent in their theology, let’s question Calvinists.” Then, I would ask the question, “How are Calvinists consistent in their theology if they hold to Jesus dying for everyone (“unlimited atonement”), yet insist that God handpicks certain individuals for salvation and bypasses others (“unconditional election”)? How can God offer Himself on behalf of every single person in the world, if He only draws a few through “irresistible grace”?
Chances are, Charles Spurgeon, one of the greatest preachers of Baptist history, probably could not answer this one. He often felt as if the doctrine of supralapsarianism was a harsh one---yet, it is consistent, if God only handpicks a few people to be saved (for where will the rest of humanity go but to Hell?). Spurgeon said the following about God unconditionally reprobating a mass of humanity to Hell:
“Do you believe that God created man and arbitrarily, sovereignly---it is the same thing---CREATED THAT MAN, WITH NO OTHER INTENTION, THAN THAT OF DAMNING HIM? Made him, and yet, for no other reason than that of destroying him forever? Well, if you can believe it, I PITY YOU, THAT IS ALL I CAN SAY: YOU DESERVE PITY, THAT YOU SHOULD THINK SO MEANLY OF GOD, WHOSE MERCY ENDURETH FOREVER” (Charles Spurgeon, “Jacob and Esau,” page 118; quoted by Ken Keathley, “Salvation and Sovereignty: A Molinist Approach.” Nashville: Broadman and Holman, 2010, page 145).
Spurgeon admits via the quote above that he is infralapsarian; however, his infralapsarianism is itself inconsistent:
“To genuinely embrace the concept of permission would require the infralapsarian to abandon some of the key tenets of Reformed theology. Berkhof recognized this when he warned, ‘Infralapsarianism really wants to explain reprobation as an act of God’s justice. It is inclined to deny either explicitly or implicitly that it is an act of the mere good pleasure of God. THIS REALLY MAKES THE DECREE OF REPROBATION A CONDITIONAL DECREE AND LEADS INTO THE ARMINIAN FOLD.’ INFRALAPSARIANS HAVE A CHOICE. IF THE DECREE TO REPROBATION IS CONDITIONAL, THEN IT IS NOT ACCORDING TO GOD’S MERE GOOD PLEASURE. IF IT IS UNCONDITIONAL, THEN IT IS NOT ACCORDING TO GOD’S PERMISSION. Infralapsarianism wants to teach that God damns the reprobate in response to their sins, but THIS WOULD ABANDON THE CLASSIC REFORMED VIEW OF GOD’S SOVEREIGNTY, WHICH IS WHY CALVIN REJECTED THE CONCEPT OF PERMISSION OUT OF HAND” (Ken Keathley, “Salvation and Sovereignty: A Molinist Approach.” Nashville: Broadman and Holman, 2010, page 146).
If Charles Spurgeon was to be consistent, he needed to hold on to supralapsarianism (the unconditional reprobation of the damned), which is something he could not do. Funny though, wasn’t he trying to “school” the Arminian camp about being “consistent”? But how could he hold on to the “conditional” reprobation of the damned while arguing “unconditional” election of the saved? Sounds a bit inconsistent to me...
What about Spurgeon’s attack on Arminianism itself? I will get into his attack on Arminianism’s “limited” atonement in my next post...
Tuesday, July 14, 2009
The Unconditional Condition
The Doctrine of Unconditional Election is as thus:
“The doctrine of election declares that God, before the foundation of the world, chose certain individuals from among the fallen members of Adam’s race to be the objects of His undeserved favor. These, and these only, He purposed to save. God could have chosen to save all men (for He had the power and authority to do so) or He could have chosen to save none (for He was under no obligation to show mercy to any)—but He did neither. Instead, He chose to save some and to exclude others. His eternal choice of particular sinners for salvation was not based upon any foreseen act or response on the part of those selected, but was based solely on His own good pleasure and sovereign will. Thus, election was not determined by, or conditioned upon, anything that men would do, but resulted entirely from God’s self-determined purpose. THOSE WHO WERE NOT CHOSEN FOR SALVATION WERE PASSED BY AND LEFT TO THEIR OWN EVIL DEVICES AND CHOICES. It is not within the creature’s jurisdiction to call into question the justice of the Creator for not choosing anyone for salvation. It is enough to know that the Judge of the earth has done right”(Steele, Thomas, & S. Lance Quinn, “The Five Points of Calvinism: Defined, Defended, and Documented.” Phillipsburg, New Jersey: P&R Publishing, 2004, pages 27-28).
According to David Steele, Curtis Thomas, and S. Lance Quinn, God chooses some for salvation—because He wants to. There is nothing that the chosen “do” in order to get selected. They are just chosen by God’s arbitrary choice. The Lord picked certain people just like a random ticket drawing—“you, not you, you, not you, not you,” etc.
And then, Steele, Thomas, and Quinn provide biblical proof of unconditional election. In their section where they state that God did not choose based on foreseen faith, they offer two verses of note:
“1 Thessalonians 1:4-5—‘For we know, brothers loved by God, that HE HAS CHOSEN YOU, BECAUSE OUR GOSPEL CAME TO YOU not only in word, but also in POWER and IN THE HOLY SPIRIT and WITH FULL CONVICTION.’
2 Thessalonians 2:13-14—‘God chose you as the first fruits to be saved, THROUGH SANCTIFICATION by the Spirit and BELIEF IN THE TRUTH. To this he called you through our gospel, so that you may obtain the glory of our Lord Jesus Christ’” (page 34).
Take a look at the first verse quoted above. “For we know, brothers loved by God, that HE HAS CHOSEN YOU.”
First off, let me say that yes, this verse discusses the concept of election. I will not disagree with that; however, the issue is WHAT kind of election, not the idea of election itself. Paul writes here that they KNOW that the believers at Thessalonica are chosen by God—because they have evidence of their election. In other words, their election has been manifested, made known, in the earthly realm. What kind of evidence was witnessed? “Because our Gospel came to you not only in WORD, but also in POWER and in the HOLY SPIRIT and with FULL CONVICTION.” Not only was the Word preached, but the power to preach the Word came; as a result of the preaching of the Word, the Holy Spirit BROUGHT FULL CONVICTION to those who listened to the Word being preached.
What does it mean to convict? Merriam-Webster’s Online Dictionary gives us the
following:
transitive verb 1 : to find or prove to be guilty 2 : to convince of error or sinfulness intransitive verb : to find a defendant guilty.
When a person is convicted of sin, they are certainly shown to be guilty of sin. But the definition I like most is #2: “to convince of error or sinfulness.” What does it mean to “convince” someone? Merriam-Webster’s Online Dictionary supplies the following definitions:
1obsolete a: to overcome by argument b: OVERPOWER, OVERCOME2obsolete : DEMONSTRATE, PROVE3: to bring (as by argument) to belief, consent, or a course of action : PERSUADE
Look at the third definition of “convince”: “to bring (as by argument) to belief, consent, or a course of action.” Basically, it means to get someone to do something, to help them understanding that your view or belief makes sense. But the one word that adequately defines “convince” is “persuade.” And what does it mean to “persuade” someone? It means to appeal to their intellect, to reason with someone.
I looked up “reason” as a verb in Merriam-Webster’s Online Dictionary and saw the following definitions:
1 a obsolete : to take part in conversation, discussion, or argument b : to talk with another so as to influence actions or opinions
2 : to use the faculty of reason so as to arrive at conclusions.
Definition #2 says it best—“To use the FACULTY OF REASON so as to arrive at conclusions.” This is why man has been given an intellect—so he can use his mental intelligence to come to well-thought-out decisions. This explains the Lord’s words to His people in Isaiah 1:
18 "Come, let us discuss this," (AJ)
says the LORD.
"Though your sins are like scarlet,
they will be as white as snow; (AK)
though they are as red as crimson,
they will be like wool.
19 If you are willing and obedient,
you will eat the good things of the land. (AL)
20 But if you refuse and rebel,
you will be devoured by the sword." (AM)
For the mouth of the LORD has spoken. (Isaiah 1:18-20, Holman Christian Standard Bible).
The word for “let us discuss this” in the Septuagint (Greek Old Testament) is “dielegxthomen,” which comes from the word “elegxo,” meaning “to bring to light, expose, convince, reprove, rebuke, punish.” So, when the Spirit convicts the Thessalonians through preaching, He exposed their sin and their guiltiness, as well as “brought to light” the truth of the Gospel and their need for a Savior. But He did this not by FORCING them to come to Christ—but through the use of their reason, their intellect, their minds. And the Spirit did this why? because it is by the mind that mankind is able to process, understand, and communicate with others.
Paul says in 1 Thessalonians 1:4-5 that the sign of the Thessalonians’ election was that the Word came, as well as power to preach, which was brought by the Spirit, who convicted the Thessalonians of sin and their need for Christ.
Look at the next passage reference, 2 Thessalonians 2:13-14—
“God chose you as the first fruits to be saved, through sanctification by the Spirit and belief in the truth. To this he called you through our gospel, so that you may obtain the glory of our Lord Jesus Christ.”
God chose (elected) the Thessalonians. But we are not only told of their election, but also the NATURE of the election—“through sanctification by the Spirit and BELIEF IN THE TRUTH.” So, the election then, is not based on God’s arbitrary pick of certain persons, but instead foreseen faith.
And these two passages show us that there is a condition to election—namely, FAITH. As a result, election CANNOT be UNCONDITIONAL. When these two thoughts are combined, one cannot have an UNCONDITIONAL CONDITION. You cannot have God picking people on the basis of His choice and those same persons choosing whether or not to believe in Him at the same time. According to Calvinists, faith is a work—so, if God selects you, then faith isn’t involved at all.
In all honesty, Calvinists have spent far too much time imposing their views on the Biblical text itself. If faith is required to receive salvation, and (in their view) faith is a work, then I think we need to look beyond unconditional election to find what the Biblical nature of election really is.
“The doctrine of election declares that God, before the foundation of the world, chose certain individuals from among the fallen members of Adam’s race to be the objects of His undeserved favor. These, and these only, He purposed to save. God could have chosen to save all men (for He had the power and authority to do so) or He could have chosen to save none (for He was under no obligation to show mercy to any)—but He did neither. Instead, He chose to save some and to exclude others. His eternal choice of particular sinners for salvation was not based upon any foreseen act or response on the part of those selected, but was based solely on His own good pleasure and sovereign will. Thus, election was not determined by, or conditioned upon, anything that men would do, but resulted entirely from God’s self-determined purpose. THOSE WHO WERE NOT CHOSEN FOR SALVATION WERE PASSED BY AND LEFT TO THEIR OWN EVIL DEVICES AND CHOICES. It is not within the creature’s jurisdiction to call into question the justice of the Creator for not choosing anyone for salvation. It is enough to know that the Judge of the earth has done right”(Steele, Thomas, & S. Lance Quinn, “The Five Points of Calvinism: Defined, Defended, and Documented.” Phillipsburg, New Jersey: P&R Publishing, 2004, pages 27-28).
According to David Steele, Curtis Thomas, and S. Lance Quinn, God chooses some for salvation—because He wants to. There is nothing that the chosen “do” in order to get selected. They are just chosen by God’s arbitrary choice. The Lord picked certain people just like a random ticket drawing—“you, not you, you, not you, not you,” etc.
And then, Steele, Thomas, and Quinn provide biblical proof of unconditional election. In their section where they state that God did not choose based on foreseen faith, they offer two verses of note:
“1 Thessalonians 1:4-5—‘For we know, brothers loved by God, that HE HAS CHOSEN YOU, BECAUSE OUR GOSPEL CAME TO YOU not only in word, but also in POWER and IN THE HOLY SPIRIT and WITH FULL CONVICTION.’
2 Thessalonians 2:13-14—‘God chose you as the first fruits to be saved, THROUGH SANCTIFICATION by the Spirit and BELIEF IN THE TRUTH. To this he called you through our gospel, so that you may obtain the glory of our Lord Jesus Christ’” (page 34).
Take a look at the first verse quoted above. “For we know, brothers loved by God, that HE HAS CHOSEN YOU.”
First off, let me say that yes, this verse discusses the concept of election. I will not disagree with that; however, the issue is WHAT kind of election, not the idea of election itself. Paul writes here that they KNOW that the believers at Thessalonica are chosen by God—because they have evidence of their election. In other words, their election has been manifested, made known, in the earthly realm. What kind of evidence was witnessed? “Because our Gospel came to you not only in WORD, but also in POWER and in the HOLY SPIRIT and with FULL CONVICTION.” Not only was the Word preached, but the power to preach the Word came; as a result of the preaching of the Word, the Holy Spirit BROUGHT FULL CONVICTION to those who listened to the Word being preached.
What does it mean to convict? Merriam-Webster’s Online Dictionary gives us the
following:
transitive verb 1 : to find or prove to be guilty 2 : to convince of error or sinfulness intransitive verb : to find a defendant guilty.
When a person is convicted of sin, they are certainly shown to be guilty of sin. But the definition I like most is #2: “to convince of error or sinfulness.” What does it mean to “convince” someone? Merriam-Webster’s Online Dictionary supplies the following definitions:
1obsolete a: to overcome by argument b: OVERPOWER, OVERCOME2obsolete : DEMONSTRATE, PROVE3: to bring (as by argument) to belief, consent, or a course of action : PERSUADE
Look at the third definition of “convince”: “to bring (as by argument) to belief, consent, or a course of action.” Basically, it means to get someone to do something, to help them understanding that your view or belief makes sense. But the one word that adequately defines “convince” is “persuade.” And what does it mean to “persuade” someone? It means to appeal to their intellect, to reason with someone.
I looked up “reason” as a verb in Merriam-Webster’s Online Dictionary and saw the following definitions:
1 a obsolete : to take part in conversation, discussion, or argument b : to talk with another so as to influence actions or opinions
2 : to use the faculty of reason so as to arrive at conclusions.
Definition #2 says it best—“To use the FACULTY OF REASON so as to arrive at conclusions.” This is why man has been given an intellect—so he can use his mental intelligence to come to well-thought-out decisions. This explains the Lord’s words to His people in Isaiah 1:
18 "Come, let us discuss this," (AJ)
says the LORD.
"Though your sins are like scarlet,
they will be as white as snow; (AK)
though they are as red as crimson,
they will be like wool.
19 If you are willing and obedient,
you will eat the good things of the land. (AL)
20 But if you refuse and rebel,
you will be devoured by the sword." (AM)
For the mouth of the LORD has spoken. (Isaiah 1:18-20, Holman Christian Standard Bible).
The word for “let us discuss this” in the Septuagint (Greek Old Testament) is “dielegxthomen,” which comes from the word “elegxo,” meaning “to bring to light, expose, convince, reprove, rebuke, punish.” So, when the Spirit convicts the Thessalonians through preaching, He exposed their sin and their guiltiness, as well as “brought to light” the truth of the Gospel and their need for a Savior. But He did this not by FORCING them to come to Christ—but through the use of their reason, their intellect, their minds. And the Spirit did this why? because it is by the mind that mankind is able to process, understand, and communicate with others.
Paul says in 1 Thessalonians 1:4-5 that the sign of the Thessalonians’ election was that the Word came, as well as power to preach, which was brought by the Spirit, who convicted the Thessalonians of sin and their need for Christ.
Look at the next passage reference, 2 Thessalonians 2:13-14—
“God chose you as the first fruits to be saved, through sanctification by the Spirit and belief in the truth. To this he called you through our gospel, so that you may obtain the glory of our Lord Jesus Christ.”
God chose (elected) the Thessalonians. But we are not only told of their election, but also the NATURE of the election—“through sanctification by the Spirit and BELIEF IN THE TRUTH.” So, the election then, is not based on God’s arbitrary pick of certain persons, but instead foreseen faith.
And these two passages show us that there is a condition to election—namely, FAITH. As a result, election CANNOT be UNCONDITIONAL. When these two thoughts are combined, one cannot have an UNCONDITIONAL CONDITION. You cannot have God picking people on the basis of His choice and those same persons choosing whether or not to believe in Him at the same time. According to Calvinists, faith is a work—so, if God selects you, then faith isn’t involved at all.
In all honesty, Calvinists have spent far too much time imposing their views on the Biblical text itself. If faith is required to receive salvation, and (in their view) faith is a work, then I think we need to look beyond unconditional election to find what the Biblical nature of election really is.
Labels:
The Five Points of Calvinism
Sunday, July 12, 2009
Divine Sovereignty and Human Responsibility: Convergent or Divergent?
“The system of truth revealed in the Scriptures is not simply one straight line, but two; and no man will ever get a right view of the gospel until he knows how to look at the two lines at once. For instance, I read in one book of the Bible, ‘The Spirit and the bride say, Come. And let him that heareth say, come. And let him that is athirst come. And whosoever will, let him take the water of life freely.’ Yet I am taught, in another part of the same inspired Word, that ‘it is not of him that willeth, nor of him that runneth, but of God that sheweth mercy.’ I see, in one place, God in providence presiding over all, and yet I see, and I cannot help seeing, THAT MAN ACTS AS HE PLEASES, AND THAT GOD HAS LEFT HIS ACTIONS, IN A GREAT MEASURE, TO HIS OWN FREE WILL. Now, if I were to declare that man was so free to act that there was no control of God over his actions, I should be driven very near to atheism; and if, on the other hand, I should declare that GOD SO OVERRULES ALL THINGS THAT MAN IS NOT FREE ENOUGH TO BE RESPONSIBLE, I should be driven at once into antinomianism or fatalism. That God predestines, and yet that man is responsible, are two facts that few can see clearly. They are believed to be INCONSISTENT AND CONTRADICTORY to each other. If, then, I find taught in one part of the Bible that everything is foreordained, THAT IS TRUE; and if I find, in another Scripture, that man is responsible for all his actions, THAT IS TRUE; AND IT IS ONLY MY FOLLY THAT LEADS ME TO IMAGINE THAT THESE TWO TRUTHS CAN EVER CONTRADICT EACH OTHER. I DO NOT BELIEVE THAT THEY CAN EVER BE WELDED INTO ONE UPON ANY EARTHLY ANVIL, but they certainly shall be one in eternity” (Charles Haddon Spurgeon, “Defense of Calvinism,” in “The Five Points of Calvinism: Defined, Defended, and Documented” by David Steele, Curtis Thomas, and S. Lance Quinn. Phillipsburg, New Jersey: P&R Publishing, 2004, page 184).
In Spurgeon’s thought, divine sovereignty and human responsibility are two lines that only converge in the mind of God. However, today, I’d like to focus on these two theological concepts and prove that both can converge.
Before I get started, though, I’d like to applaud Spurgeon on his comments regarding both emphases of Scripture. Like Spurgeon, I too, believe that both are emphasized in Scripture. And, like Spurgeon, I also believe that both are consistent and are NOT contradictory. If the two concepts are contradictory, then the Bible as a whole comes into question. However, a proper hermeneutical rule I keep in mind is that Scripture can never contradict itself; in other words, every verse supports every other verse. So, if there is a seemingly contradictory appearance of two concepts, we have to find what is needed to reconcile them.
Those who say that divine sovereignty and human responsibility cannot reconcile are those who view human responsibility as “sovereignty of man.” They say, then, that how can God be in control of all things and yet, man has power over his actions? I have an answer: God, in His sovereignty, gave man free will, power and responsibility over his actions. Arminians answer this question by affirming their tenet of “libertarian free will” in their theology. What libertarian free will shows us is that God gives man choices—within boundaries. Therefore, man will always have a LIMITED number of CHOICES over what he can and cannot do. This way, man gets to choose—and God limits His choice, thereby retaining control over all of life’s events.
If God has ABSOLUTE control of all things and events, then, of course, man has no choice whatsoever—EXCEPT God caused it! But what about if God doesn’t have ABSOLUTE sovereignty over all of life? What about if God has GENERAL sovereignty?
What is “general sovereignty?” Brothers David and Randall Basinger define it in this matter:
“These Christians [those who deny specific sovereignty] believe that human freedom does place limitations on God’s control over earthly affairs. These individuals agree with the theological determinist that IF human actions are determined by God, then God can maintain total control over all events in the world. They believe, though, that our free choices are not determined. In other words, they hold to a self-deterministic (or libertarian) understanding of human freedom. Thus they maintain that to the degree to which God gives us freedom he does not control earthly affairs. In a world like ours, they argue, God has the ability to accomplish general goals. But he cannot assure that all SPECIFIC events will be in keeping with his will” (David and Randall Basinger, “Predestination and Free Will: Four Views on Divine Sovereignty and Human Freedom.” Downers Grove: InterVarsity Press, 1986, page 13.)
There are two views of sovereignty: one, ABSOLUTE; the other, GENERAL. If there is a such thing as human responsibility, then power must come along with that responsibility. I’ll set up a syllogism:
I. With power comes responsibility.
II. Human responsibility exists.
III. Therefore, if responsibility exists, and power comes along with it, then humans have been given freedom (human power) over their decisions.
Now the next question becomes, what to make of this human power and human responsibility? Does human freedom and responsibility fit under ABSOLUTE sovereignty or GENERAL sovereignty? To see if this works, let’s examine both separately.
Absolute sovereignty says that God is the CAUSE of every event and action. God determines EVERY SPECIFIC ACTION of EVERY SINGLE INDIVIDUAL! Calvinists are more likely to endorse absolute sovereignty; they believe that in order for God’s purposes to be achieved, He must dictate EVERY SINGLE ACTION. However, if absolute sovereignty is true, how do we account for the power and responsibility that man has? Surely, if man is a creation of God (which he is), then human power (and subsequent responsibility) must fit under the umbrella of God’s sovereignty (for nothing lies outside of the sovereignty of God). Yet and still, most Calvinists cry out that God’s Sovereignty and man’s power (and responsibility) are two concepts that we can’t reconcile. As I said earlier, how logical is this?
So then, how does human power and human responsibility fit under the umbrella of the Sovereignty of God? Proponents of Absolute Sovereignty say that God OVERRIDES human will in order to achieve His purposes. As a result, then, EVERY ACTION that man makes, every choice he selects, is done because of God. According to such a view, God would then become responsible for the Fall, sin, and evil. Funny, but doesn’t James 1 CONTRADICT this statement?
Proponents of General Sovereignty say that God works WITH the human will to achieve His purposes for all of creation. Sometime ago, I discussed Romans 8:28 in some detail. Romans 8:28 says, “And we know that all things WORK TOGETHER for the good of them that love God…” It doesn’t say that “all things are good,” but rather that “all things WORK TOGETHER” for good. God’s purposes are not thwarted. In General Sovereignty, although God maintains control over all things, man is given the power of choice and the responsibility over his choices. This comes to light especially with the problem of evil. The problem of evil is one of the strongest “trump cards” in favor of Arminianism. According to general sovereignty, man is given power of choice, which explains why man is allowed to sin—but man is also given responsibility for choosing that which is opposed to God’s standard. However, no matter the amount of evil in the world, “All things work together for the good of them that love God” (Rom. 8:28); this means, therefore, that no matter how intense the evil, history will culminate as God intended it to—in heavenly bliss for those who love Him, in eternal damnation for those who choose to “go their own way.” And yes, God’s glory is maintained—His goodness towards those who love Him, His justice and wrath towards those who don’t.
In absolute sovereignty, there is no room for human decision as choice. Human decision is reduced to an “effect” of God’s causation instead of becoming the cause of a contingent event. If one wants to give the power of choice its proper place, then he or she must consider general sovereignty as the key to reconciling divine sovereignty and human responsibility.
According to the great Baptist preacher Charles Haddon Spurgeon, these two concepts are not reconcilable to us, but they are to God. I would like to say, however, that these two concepts do converge: God, in His sovereignty, gave man the power (and responsibility) of choice. By so doing, the Lord LIMITED HIMSELF in regards to the affairs of earth (since in Genesis 1:26-28 man is given “dominion” over the earth). As God’s children, we know the importance of the great power and responsibility God has given to man; therefore, we constantly pray the words, “Your kingdom come. Your will be done on earth as it is in heaven” (Matthew 6:10, HCSB).
In Spurgeon’s thought, divine sovereignty and human responsibility are two lines that only converge in the mind of God. However, today, I’d like to focus on these two theological concepts and prove that both can converge.
Before I get started, though, I’d like to applaud Spurgeon on his comments regarding both emphases of Scripture. Like Spurgeon, I too, believe that both are emphasized in Scripture. And, like Spurgeon, I also believe that both are consistent and are NOT contradictory. If the two concepts are contradictory, then the Bible as a whole comes into question. However, a proper hermeneutical rule I keep in mind is that Scripture can never contradict itself; in other words, every verse supports every other verse. So, if there is a seemingly contradictory appearance of two concepts, we have to find what is needed to reconcile them.
Those who say that divine sovereignty and human responsibility cannot reconcile are those who view human responsibility as “sovereignty of man.” They say, then, that how can God be in control of all things and yet, man has power over his actions? I have an answer: God, in His sovereignty, gave man free will, power and responsibility over his actions. Arminians answer this question by affirming their tenet of “libertarian free will” in their theology. What libertarian free will shows us is that God gives man choices—within boundaries. Therefore, man will always have a LIMITED number of CHOICES over what he can and cannot do. This way, man gets to choose—and God limits His choice, thereby retaining control over all of life’s events.
If God has ABSOLUTE control of all things and events, then, of course, man has no choice whatsoever—EXCEPT God caused it! But what about if God doesn’t have ABSOLUTE sovereignty over all of life? What about if God has GENERAL sovereignty?
What is “general sovereignty?” Brothers David and Randall Basinger define it in this matter:
“These Christians [those who deny specific sovereignty] believe that human freedom does place limitations on God’s control over earthly affairs. These individuals agree with the theological determinist that IF human actions are determined by God, then God can maintain total control over all events in the world. They believe, though, that our free choices are not determined. In other words, they hold to a self-deterministic (or libertarian) understanding of human freedom. Thus they maintain that to the degree to which God gives us freedom he does not control earthly affairs. In a world like ours, they argue, God has the ability to accomplish general goals. But he cannot assure that all SPECIFIC events will be in keeping with his will” (David and Randall Basinger, “Predestination and Free Will: Four Views on Divine Sovereignty and Human Freedom.” Downers Grove: InterVarsity Press, 1986, page 13.)
There are two views of sovereignty: one, ABSOLUTE; the other, GENERAL. If there is a such thing as human responsibility, then power must come along with that responsibility. I’ll set up a syllogism:
I. With power comes responsibility.
II. Human responsibility exists.
III. Therefore, if responsibility exists, and power comes along with it, then humans have been given freedom (human power) over their decisions.
Now the next question becomes, what to make of this human power and human responsibility? Does human freedom and responsibility fit under ABSOLUTE sovereignty or GENERAL sovereignty? To see if this works, let’s examine both separately.
Absolute sovereignty says that God is the CAUSE of every event and action. God determines EVERY SPECIFIC ACTION of EVERY SINGLE INDIVIDUAL! Calvinists are more likely to endorse absolute sovereignty; they believe that in order for God’s purposes to be achieved, He must dictate EVERY SINGLE ACTION. However, if absolute sovereignty is true, how do we account for the power and responsibility that man has? Surely, if man is a creation of God (which he is), then human power (and subsequent responsibility) must fit under the umbrella of God’s sovereignty (for nothing lies outside of the sovereignty of God). Yet and still, most Calvinists cry out that God’s Sovereignty and man’s power (and responsibility) are two concepts that we can’t reconcile. As I said earlier, how logical is this?
So then, how does human power and human responsibility fit under the umbrella of the Sovereignty of God? Proponents of Absolute Sovereignty say that God OVERRIDES human will in order to achieve His purposes. As a result, then, EVERY ACTION that man makes, every choice he selects, is done because of God. According to such a view, God would then become responsible for the Fall, sin, and evil. Funny, but doesn’t James 1 CONTRADICT this statement?
Proponents of General Sovereignty say that God works WITH the human will to achieve His purposes for all of creation. Sometime ago, I discussed Romans 8:28 in some detail. Romans 8:28 says, “And we know that all things WORK TOGETHER for the good of them that love God…” It doesn’t say that “all things are good,” but rather that “all things WORK TOGETHER” for good. God’s purposes are not thwarted. In General Sovereignty, although God maintains control over all things, man is given the power of choice and the responsibility over his choices. This comes to light especially with the problem of evil. The problem of evil is one of the strongest “trump cards” in favor of Arminianism. According to general sovereignty, man is given power of choice, which explains why man is allowed to sin—but man is also given responsibility for choosing that which is opposed to God’s standard. However, no matter the amount of evil in the world, “All things work together for the good of them that love God” (Rom. 8:28); this means, therefore, that no matter how intense the evil, history will culminate as God intended it to—in heavenly bliss for those who love Him, in eternal damnation for those who choose to “go their own way.” And yes, God’s glory is maintained—His goodness towards those who love Him, His justice and wrath towards those who don’t.
In absolute sovereignty, there is no room for human decision as choice. Human decision is reduced to an “effect” of God’s causation instead of becoming the cause of a contingent event. If one wants to give the power of choice its proper place, then he or she must consider general sovereignty as the key to reconciling divine sovereignty and human responsibility.
According to the great Baptist preacher Charles Haddon Spurgeon, these two concepts are not reconcilable to us, but they are to God. I would like to say, however, that these two concepts do converge: God, in His sovereignty, gave man the power (and responsibility) of choice. By so doing, the Lord LIMITED HIMSELF in regards to the affairs of earth (since in Genesis 1:26-28 man is given “dominion” over the earth). As God’s children, we know the importance of the great power and responsibility God has given to man; therefore, we constantly pray the words, “Your kingdom come. Your will be done on earth as it is in heaven” (Matthew 6:10, HCSB).
Labels:
The Five Points of Calvinism
Thursday, July 9, 2009
Spurgeon's Lapse, Part III
“Once again, if it was Christ’s intention to save all men, HOW DEPLORABLY HAS HE BEEN DISAPPOINTED, for we have His own testimony that there is a lake which burneth with fire and brimstone, and into that pit of woe have been cast some of the very persons who, according to the theory of universal redemption, were bought with His blood. That seems to me a conception a thousand times more repulsive than any of those consequences which are said to be associated with the Calvinistic and Christian doctrine of special and particular redemption. To think that my Saviour died for men who were or are in hell, seems a supposition too horrible for me to entertain. To imagine for a moment that He was the substitute for all the sons of men, and that God, having first punished the substitute, afterwards punished the sinners themselves, seems to conflict with all my ideas of divine justice” (Charles Haddon Spurgeon, “Defense of Calvinism”).
In Spurgeon’s Lapse Part III, I am gonna continue to tackle the long extensive quote I put in part II. We placed the portion we will tackle today above.
Spurgeon focuses on the disappointment of those who reject the Cross; he then uses this to argue a limited atonement. What struck me the most was that he uses the concept of Hell itself to argue that Christ could not have died for everyone. In short, those who went to Hell did so because “Christ didn’t die for them.” This actually makes me quite sick to my stomach—to think that Christ only died for a few people!
Well, since Spurgeon wrote it, let’s look at the concept of Hell. To do this, I will tackle one passage:
41 Then He will also say to those on the left, 'Depart from Me, you who are cursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the Devil and his angels! (S) 42 For I was hungry and you gave Me nothing to eat; I was thirsty and you gave Me nothing to drink; 43 I was a stranger and you didn't take Me in; I was naked and you didn't clothe Me, sick and in prison and you didn't take care of Me.' 44 "Then they too will answer, 'Lord, when did we see You hungry, or thirsty, or a stranger, or without clothes, or sick, or in prison, and not help You?' 45 "Then He will answer them, 'I assure you: Whatever you did not do for one of the least of these, you did not do for Me either. (T) ' 46 "And they will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life." (Matthew 25: 41-46, Holman Christian Standard Bible)
Look at verse 41: the eternal fire was not prepared for MANKIND, but “FOR THE DEVIL AND HIS ANGELS!” Nowhere in Scripture are we ever told that Hell was prepared for people.
So if Hell was originally prepared for Satan and the fallen angels, then why does Jesus speak of humanity going to Hell?
“And they (those on the left) will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life.” (Matthew 25:46, HCSB)
Is it because Christ didn’t die for them all? No. They are going to Hell because their works condemn them:
42 For I was hungry and you gave Me nothing to eat; I was thirsty
and you gave Me nothing to drink; 43 I was a stranger and you didn't take Me in; I was naked and you didn't clothe Me, sick and in prison and you didn't take care of Me.' (Matthew 25:42-43, HCSB)
The cursed are those who did nothing for the Lord, those who refused to do anything that would reflect their Savior. And this section comes at the end of Matthew chapter 25, where, earlier, we find that the five foolish virgins miss the Wedding Banquet because they carry no oil with them in their lamps!
I agree with Spurgeon on one thing: it seems unthinkable that, after the Lord Jesus died, that souls would STILL go to Hell; however, that is the case of fallen humanity.
And I think that this is the pitfall of not just the great Charles Haddon Spurgeon, but of all Calvinists: they desire to affirm fallen humanity and “being dead in trespasses and sins” until it gets to the atonement. At that moment, suddenly, Christ only died for people who accept Him. They seem to forget Jesus’ words to Nicodemus in John 3:16—18 (HCSB):
16 "For God loved (Y) the world in this way: He gave His One and Only (Z) Son, (AA) so that everyone who believes in Him will not perish but have eternal life. (AB) 17 For God did not send His Son into the world that He might judge (AC) the world, but that the world might be saved through Him. 18 Anyone who believes in Him is not judged, (AD) but anyone who does not believe is already judged, (AE) because he has not believed in the name (AF) of the One and Only Son (AG) of God.
Look at verse 17: “For God did not send His Son into the world that He might JUDGE the world, but that the world MIGHT BE SAVED through Him.” The Father’s goal was to save the world, not condemn the world to Hell; however, notice the POTENTIALITY in those words—the world MIGHT be saved, not WILL BE saved. I think these words show us the POSSIBILITY and not the PROBABILITY. But such is fallen humanity; however, for those who accept Christ’s work on the Cross and receive Him into their hearts, they show the efficacy of Calvary…
In Spurgeon’s Lapse Part III, I am gonna continue to tackle the long extensive quote I put in part II. We placed the portion we will tackle today above.
Spurgeon focuses on the disappointment of those who reject the Cross; he then uses this to argue a limited atonement. What struck me the most was that he uses the concept of Hell itself to argue that Christ could not have died for everyone. In short, those who went to Hell did so because “Christ didn’t die for them.” This actually makes me quite sick to my stomach—to think that Christ only died for a few people!
Well, since Spurgeon wrote it, let’s look at the concept of Hell. To do this, I will tackle one passage:
41 Then He will also say to those on the left, 'Depart from Me, you who are cursed, into the eternal fire prepared for the Devil and his angels! (S) 42 For I was hungry and you gave Me nothing to eat; I was thirsty and you gave Me nothing to drink; 43 I was a stranger and you didn't take Me in; I was naked and you didn't clothe Me, sick and in prison and you didn't take care of Me.' 44 "Then they too will answer, 'Lord, when did we see You hungry, or thirsty, or a stranger, or without clothes, or sick, or in prison, and not help You?' 45 "Then He will answer them, 'I assure you: Whatever you did not do for one of the least of these, you did not do for Me either. (T) ' 46 "And they will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life." (Matthew 25: 41-46, Holman Christian Standard Bible)
Look at verse 41: the eternal fire was not prepared for MANKIND, but “FOR THE DEVIL AND HIS ANGELS!” Nowhere in Scripture are we ever told that Hell was prepared for people.
So if Hell was originally prepared for Satan and the fallen angels, then why does Jesus speak of humanity going to Hell?
“And they (those on the left) will go away into eternal punishment, but the righteous into eternal life.” (Matthew 25:46, HCSB)
Is it because Christ didn’t die for them all? No. They are going to Hell because their works condemn them:
42 For I was hungry and you gave Me nothing to eat; I was thirsty
and you gave Me nothing to drink; 43 I was a stranger and you didn't take Me in; I was naked and you didn't clothe Me, sick and in prison and you didn't take care of Me.' (Matthew 25:42-43, HCSB)
The cursed are those who did nothing for the Lord, those who refused to do anything that would reflect their Savior. And this section comes at the end of Matthew chapter 25, where, earlier, we find that the five foolish virgins miss the Wedding Banquet because they carry no oil with them in their lamps!
I agree with Spurgeon on one thing: it seems unthinkable that, after the Lord Jesus died, that souls would STILL go to Hell; however, that is the case of fallen humanity.
And I think that this is the pitfall of not just the great Charles Haddon Spurgeon, but of all Calvinists: they desire to affirm fallen humanity and “being dead in trespasses and sins” until it gets to the atonement. At that moment, suddenly, Christ only died for people who accept Him. They seem to forget Jesus’ words to Nicodemus in John 3:16—18 (HCSB):
16 "For God loved (Y) the world in this way: He gave His One and Only (Z) Son, (AA) so that everyone who believes in Him will not perish but have eternal life. (AB) 17 For God did not send His Son into the world that He might judge (AC) the world, but that the world might be saved through Him. 18 Anyone who believes in Him is not judged, (AD) but anyone who does not believe is already judged, (AE) because he has not believed in the name (AF) of the One and Only Son (AG) of God.
Look at verse 17: “For God did not send His Son into the world that He might JUDGE the world, but that the world MIGHT BE SAVED through Him.” The Father’s goal was to save the world, not condemn the world to Hell; however, notice the POTENTIALITY in those words—the world MIGHT be saved, not WILL BE saved. I think these words show us the POSSIBILITY and not the PROBABILITY. But such is fallen humanity; however, for those who accept Christ’s work on the Cross and receive Him into their hearts, they show the efficacy of Calvary…
Labels:
The Five Points of Calvinism
Spurgeon's Lapse, Part II
I’m back again today to continue examining Spurgeon’s “Defense of Calvinism.” Spurgeon writes the following regarding the atonement:
“Some persons love the doctrine of universal atonement because they say, ‘It is so beautiful. It is a lovely idea that Christ should have died for all men; it commends itself,’ they say, ‘to the instincts of humanity; there is something in it full of joy and beauty.’ I admit there is, but beauty may be often associated with falsehood. There is much which I might admire in the theory of universal redemption, but I will just show what the supposition necessarily involves. If Christ on His cross intended to save every man, then HE INTENDED TO SAVE THOSE WHO WERE LOST BEFORE HE DIED. If the doctrine be true, that He died for all men, then HE DIED FOR SOME WHO WERE IN HELL BEFORE HE CAME INTO THIS WORLD, for doubtless THERE WERE EVEN THEN MYRIADS THERE WHO HAD BEEN CAST AWAY BECAUSE OF THEIR SINS. Once again, if it was Christ’s intention to save all men, HOW DEPLORABLY HAS HE BEEN DISAPPOINTED, for we have His own testimony that there is a lake which burneth with fire and brimstone, and into that pit of woe have been cast some of the very persons who, according to the theory of universal redemption, were bought with His blood. That seems to me a conception a thousand times more repulsive than any of those consequences which are said to be associated with the Calvinistic and Christian doctrine of special and particular redemption. To think that my Saviour died for men who were or are in hell, seems a supposition too horrible for me to entertain. To imagine for a moment that He was the substitute for all the sons of men, and that God, having first punished the substitute, afterwards punished the sinners themselves, seems to conflict with all my ideas of divine justice. That Christ should offer an atonement and satisfaction for the sins of all men, and that afterwards some of those very men should be punished for the sins for which Christ had already atoned, appears to me to be the MOST MONSTROUS INIQUITY THAT COULD EVER HAVE BEEN IMPUTED to Saturn, to Janus, to the goddess of the Thugs, or to the most diabolical heathen deities. God forbid that we should ever think thus of Jehovah, the just and wise and good!” (Charles Haddon Spurgeon, “Defense of Calvinism.” Quoted in the book “The Five Points of Calvinism: Defined, Defended, and Documented (Second Edition)” by David Steele, Curtis Thomas, and S. Lance Quinn. Phillipsburg, NJ: P&R Publishing, 2004)
Yes, you read Spurgeon’s words above right—if Christ died for every man, then He died for men who were already citizens of Hell. But there are a few problems with this statement: first, it disregards the time the Father chose for the Incarnation of the Son. Read these words from Galatians:
4 But when the completion of the time came, God sent His Son, (D) born of a woman, (E) born under the law, 5 to redeem those under the law, so that we might receive adoption as sons. (Galatians 4:4-5, Holman Christian Standard Bible).
The Lord chose to send His Son at the time that pleased Him. It is not up to me to question that He sent His Son after two thousand years or so had passed. The point is, He did it because it was a part of His plan.
Next, Spurgeon overlooks the fact that the saints of the Old Testament were approved in the same way that the New Testament saints were approved: by faith in the Lord.
Hebrews 4 tells us that the Israelites received the same message as present believers:
1 Therefore, while the promise remains of entering His rest, let us fear so that none of you should miss it. [a] 2 For we also have received the good news just as they did; but the message they heard did not benefit them, since they were not united with those who heard it in faith (A) [b] 3 (for we who have believed enter the rest), in keeping with what [c] He has said:
So I swore in My anger,
they will not enter My rest. (B) (C)
And yet His works have been finished since the foundation of the world, 4 for somewhere He has spoken about the seventh day in this way:
And on the seventh day
God rested from all His works. (D) (E)
5 Again, in that passage [He says], They will never enter My rest. (F) 6 Since it remains for some to enter it, and those who formerly received the good news did not enter because of disobedience, (G) 7 again, He specifies a certain day— today —speaking through David after such a long time, as previously stated:
Today if you hear His voice,
do not harden your hearts. (H) (I)
8 For if Joshua (J) had given them rest, He would not have spoken later about another day. 9 A Sabbath rest remains, therefore, for God's people. 10 For the person who has entered His rest has rested from his own works, just as God did from His. (K) 11 Let us then make every effort to enter that rest, so that no one will fall into the same pattern of disobedience. (Hebrews 4:1-11, HCSB).
As Hebrews 4 shows us, the Israelites received the SAME GOOD NEWS—but they did not obtain the promise because of unbelief. So they didn’t hear a different message than us! Contrary to modern thought, we are no more special or prized than God’s Israel of the Old Testament. And Paul tells us to be cautious lest we, like national Israel, experience God’s wrath (Romans 11:17-24).
In Hebrews 4:5, we are told that the Jews failed to enter the Promised Land—and thus, “it remains for some to enter it…” The same rest that they were supposed to enter is now open to us to enter it. What this tells us is that, while we tend to think of the Promised Land as just physical territory, the Promised Land was Heaven. For the writer of Hebrews says the following about Abraham leaving his home:
9 By faith he stayed as a foreigner in the land of promise, living in tents with Isaac and Jacob, co-heirs of the same promise. (H) 10 For he was looking forward to the city that has foundations, whose architect and builder is God. (Hebrews 11:9-10, HCSB)
So, while Abraham did enter the “land of promise,” the physical territory that God desired to give him, he anticipated a different territory altogether: a heavenly one. This is why the writer of Hebrews says, “He was looking forward to the city that has foundations, WHOSE ARCHITECT AND BUILDER IS GOD.” And what territory is this? Heaven. Paul described our immortal form in this manner:
1 For we know that if our earthly house, (A) a tent, (B) [a] is destroyed, we have a building from God, a house [b] not made with hands, (C) eternal in the heavens. (2 Corinthians 5:1, HCSB).
The new incorruption will be made by God, just as the heavenly territory has been built by God. He promised to go away to prepare a place for us—and He promised to return to take us to be with Him (John 14:2-3).
Last but not least, Hebrews 11 gives us “The Roll Call of Faith,” which shows us all the faithful gone on before us who pleased God by faith.
Let’s examine the Old Testament saints:
4 By faith Abel offered to God a better sacrifice than Cain [did]. By this he was approved as a righteous man, because God approved his gifts, and even though he is dead, he still speaks through this. (C) 5 By faith, Enoch was taken away so that he did not experience death, and he was not to be found because God took him away. (D) For prior to his transformation he was approved, having pleased God. (E) 6 Now without faith it is impossible to please God, for the one who draws near to Him must believe that He exists and rewards those who seek Him. 7 By faith Noah, after being warned about what was not yet seen, in reverence built an ark to deliver his family. By this he condemned the world and became an heir of the righteousness that comes by faith. (F) 8 By faith Abraham, when he was called, obeyed and went out to a place he was going to receive as an inheritance; he went out, not knowing where he was going. (G) 9 By faith he stayed as a foreigner in the land of promise, living in tents with Isaac and Jacob, co-heirs of the same promise. (H) 10 For he was looking forward to the city that has foundations, whose architect and builder is God. (I) 11 By faith even Sarah herself, when she was barren, received power to conceive offspring, even though she was past the age, since she [e] considered that the One who had promised was faithful. (J) 12 And therefore from one man—in fact, from one as good as dead—came offspring as numerous as the stars of heaven and as innumerable as the grains of sand by the seashore. (K) 13 These all died in faith without having received the promises, but they saw them from a distance, (L) greeted them, and confessed that they were foreigners and temporary residents on the earth. (M) 14 Now those who say such things make it clear that they are seeking a homeland. 15 If they had been remembering that land they came from, they would have had opportunity to return. 16 But they now aspire to a better land—a heavenly one. Therefore God is not ashamed to be called their God, for He has prepared a city for them. (N) (Hebrews 11:4-16, HCSB).
From Abel forward, faith was always required. Notice that in Genesis 4 we are told that “The Lord had regard FOR ABEL and his offering” (Gen. 4:4b, HCSB). Verse 13 tells us that the roll call of faith “DIED IN FAITH without having received the promises.” They embraced the promises of God even though they didn’t live to see them fulfilled. Because of their faith, however, “God is not ashamed to be called their God, for He has prepared a city for them.” They will receive the reward for their faith and endurance. Even Noah became “an heir of the righteousness that is by faith.”
We know that they received the same message (as we’re told from Hebrews 4), and that, like us, they had to respond to it in faith. But how can those of the Old Testament have received the same message if Christ hadn’t come to earth in the Incarnation yet? Peter answers this superbly:
10 Concerning this salvation, the prophets (AB) who prophesied about the grace that would come to you searched and carefully investigated. 11 They inquired into what time or what circumstances [e] the Spirit of Christ (AC) within them was indicating when He testified in advance (AD) to the messianic sufferings (AE) [f] and the glories (AF) that would follow. [g] 12 It was revealed to them that they were not serving themselves but you concerning things that have now been announced to you through those who preached the gospel to you (AG) by the Holy Spirit sent from heaven. (1 Peter 1:10-12, HCSB)
The prophets had “the Spirit of Christ within them” when they prophesied of Christ’s sufferings and His glory. The Old Testament is full of references to Christ’s suffering and glory. For instance, there are the Suffering Servant passages of Isaiah 52-53. Psalm 22 is another regarding Christ’s sufferings. And Peter’s sermons in Acts are full of Old Testament prophecy concerning Christ. So within the Old Testament writers, the Spirit lived and used them to testify of Christ, the One who was to come.
In short, the Old Testament humanity heard the same message that we hear—except they heard of what was TO COME, we hear of what HAS ALREADY COME!
So when Spurgeon says that Christ couldn’t have died for all because of those who already died in their sins, I have to respond that those who died in wickedness made their choice—against God and His righteous standard. Their spending eternity in Hell, then, is the consequence of their choices.
To conclude this post, I would like to use some of the narrative of Luke 16 regarding the Parable of Lazarus and the Rich Man. The rich man lived in luxury, while Lazarus sat at the gate, eating crumbs and begging for mercy. But when the two died, Lazarus ended up in heaven while the rich man went to hell. The rich man, understanding how wrong he was, finally wants to help his relatives who are still alive:
27 " 'Father,' he said, 'then I beg you to send him to my father's house— 28 because I have five brothers—to warn (AL) them, so they won't also come to this place of torment.'
29 "But Abraham said, 'They have Moses and the prophets; (AM) they should listen to them.' (Luke 16:27-29, HCSB)
The Old Testament humanity had the prophets to listen to, who foretold of Christ and His suffering and glory. If that didn’t do it, nothing else would. Today we have those called by God to teach and preach the Word; if we don’t listen to the Word, then nothing else will do—even if someone should rise from the dead and tell us that it is all true.
“Some persons love the doctrine of universal atonement because they say, ‘It is so beautiful. It is a lovely idea that Christ should have died for all men; it commends itself,’ they say, ‘to the instincts of humanity; there is something in it full of joy and beauty.’ I admit there is, but beauty may be often associated with falsehood. There is much which I might admire in the theory of universal redemption, but I will just show what the supposition necessarily involves. If Christ on His cross intended to save every man, then HE INTENDED TO SAVE THOSE WHO WERE LOST BEFORE HE DIED. If the doctrine be true, that He died for all men, then HE DIED FOR SOME WHO WERE IN HELL BEFORE HE CAME INTO THIS WORLD, for doubtless THERE WERE EVEN THEN MYRIADS THERE WHO HAD BEEN CAST AWAY BECAUSE OF THEIR SINS. Once again, if it was Christ’s intention to save all men, HOW DEPLORABLY HAS HE BEEN DISAPPOINTED, for we have His own testimony that there is a lake which burneth with fire and brimstone, and into that pit of woe have been cast some of the very persons who, according to the theory of universal redemption, were bought with His blood. That seems to me a conception a thousand times more repulsive than any of those consequences which are said to be associated with the Calvinistic and Christian doctrine of special and particular redemption. To think that my Saviour died for men who were or are in hell, seems a supposition too horrible for me to entertain. To imagine for a moment that He was the substitute for all the sons of men, and that God, having first punished the substitute, afterwards punished the sinners themselves, seems to conflict with all my ideas of divine justice. That Christ should offer an atonement and satisfaction for the sins of all men, and that afterwards some of those very men should be punished for the sins for which Christ had already atoned, appears to me to be the MOST MONSTROUS INIQUITY THAT COULD EVER HAVE BEEN IMPUTED to Saturn, to Janus, to the goddess of the Thugs, or to the most diabolical heathen deities. God forbid that we should ever think thus of Jehovah, the just and wise and good!” (Charles Haddon Spurgeon, “Defense of Calvinism.” Quoted in the book “The Five Points of Calvinism: Defined, Defended, and Documented (Second Edition)” by David Steele, Curtis Thomas, and S. Lance Quinn. Phillipsburg, NJ: P&R Publishing, 2004)
Yes, you read Spurgeon’s words above right—if Christ died for every man, then He died for men who were already citizens of Hell. But there are a few problems with this statement: first, it disregards the time the Father chose for the Incarnation of the Son. Read these words from Galatians:
4 But when the completion of the time came, God sent His Son, (D) born of a woman, (E) born under the law, 5 to redeem those under the law, so that we might receive adoption as sons. (Galatians 4:4-5, Holman Christian Standard Bible).
The Lord chose to send His Son at the time that pleased Him. It is not up to me to question that He sent His Son after two thousand years or so had passed. The point is, He did it because it was a part of His plan.
Next, Spurgeon overlooks the fact that the saints of the Old Testament were approved in the same way that the New Testament saints were approved: by faith in the Lord.
Hebrews 4 tells us that the Israelites received the same message as present believers:
1 Therefore, while the promise remains of entering His rest, let us fear so that none of you should miss it. [a] 2 For we also have received the good news just as they did; but the message they heard did not benefit them, since they were not united with those who heard it in faith (A) [b] 3 (for we who have believed enter the rest), in keeping with what [c] He has said:
So I swore in My anger,
they will not enter My rest. (B) (C)
And yet His works have been finished since the foundation of the world, 4 for somewhere He has spoken about the seventh day in this way:
And on the seventh day
God rested from all His works. (D) (E)
5 Again, in that passage [He says], They will never enter My rest. (F) 6 Since it remains for some to enter it, and those who formerly received the good news did not enter because of disobedience, (G) 7 again, He specifies a certain day— today —speaking through David after such a long time, as previously stated:
Today if you hear His voice,
do not harden your hearts. (H) (I)
8 For if Joshua (J) had given them rest, He would not have spoken later about another day. 9 A Sabbath rest remains, therefore, for God's people. 10 For the person who has entered His rest has rested from his own works, just as God did from His. (K) 11 Let us then make every effort to enter that rest, so that no one will fall into the same pattern of disobedience. (Hebrews 4:1-11, HCSB).
As Hebrews 4 shows us, the Israelites received the SAME GOOD NEWS—but they did not obtain the promise because of unbelief. So they didn’t hear a different message than us! Contrary to modern thought, we are no more special or prized than God’s Israel of the Old Testament. And Paul tells us to be cautious lest we, like national Israel, experience God’s wrath (Romans 11:17-24).
In Hebrews 4:5, we are told that the Jews failed to enter the Promised Land—and thus, “it remains for some to enter it…” The same rest that they were supposed to enter is now open to us to enter it. What this tells us is that, while we tend to think of the Promised Land as just physical territory, the Promised Land was Heaven. For the writer of Hebrews says the following about Abraham leaving his home:
9 By faith he stayed as a foreigner in the land of promise, living in tents with Isaac and Jacob, co-heirs of the same promise. (H) 10 For he was looking forward to the city that has foundations, whose architect and builder is God. (Hebrews 11:9-10, HCSB)
So, while Abraham did enter the “land of promise,” the physical territory that God desired to give him, he anticipated a different territory altogether: a heavenly one. This is why the writer of Hebrews says, “He was looking forward to the city that has foundations, WHOSE ARCHITECT AND BUILDER IS GOD.” And what territory is this? Heaven. Paul described our immortal form in this manner:
1 For we know that if our earthly house, (A) a tent, (B) [a] is destroyed, we have a building from God, a house [b] not made with hands, (C) eternal in the heavens. (2 Corinthians 5:1, HCSB).
The new incorruption will be made by God, just as the heavenly territory has been built by God. He promised to go away to prepare a place for us—and He promised to return to take us to be with Him (John 14:2-3).
Last but not least, Hebrews 11 gives us “The Roll Call of Faith,” which shows us all the faithful gone on before us who pleased God by faith.
Let’s examine the Old Testament saints:
4 By faith Abel offered to God a better sacrifice than Cain [did]. By this he was approved as a righteous man, because God approved his gifts, and even though he is dead, he still speaks through this. (C) 5 By faith, Enoch was taken away so that he did not experience death, and he was not to be found because God took him away. (D) For prior to his transformation he was approved, having pleased God. (E) 6 Now without faith it is impossible to please God, for the one who draws near to Him must believe that He exists and rewards those who seek Him. 7 By faith Noah, after being warned about what was not yet seen, in reverence built an ark to deliver his family. By this he condemned the world and became an heir of the righteousness that comes by faith. (F) 8 By faith Abraham, when he was called, obeyed and went out to a place he was going to receive as an inheritance; he went out, not knowing where he was going. (G) 9 By faith he stayed as a foreigner in the land of promise, living in tents with Isaac and Jacob, co-heirs of the same promise. (H) 10 For he was looking forward to the city that has foundations, whose architect and builder is God. (I) 11 By faith even Sarah herself, when she was barren, received power to conceive offspring, even though she was past the age, since she [e] considered that the One who had promised was faithful. (J) 12 And therefore from one man—in fact, from one as good as dead—came offspring as numerous as the stars of heaven and as innumerable as the grains of sand by the seashore. (K) 13 These all died in faith without having received the promises, but they saw them from a distance, (L) greeted them, and confessed that they were foreigners and temporary residents on the earth. (M) 14 Now those who say such things make it clear that they are seeking a homeland. 15 If they had been remembering that land they came from, they would have had opportunity to return. 16 But they now aspire to a better land—a heavenly one. Therefore God is not ashamed to be called their God, for He has prepared a city for them. (N) (Hebrews 11:4-16, HCSB).
From Abel forward, faith was always required. Notice that in Genesis 4 we are told that “The Lord had regard FOR ABEL and his offering” (Gen. 4:4b, HCSB). Verse 13 tells us that the roll call of faith “DIED IN FAITH without having received the promises.” They embraced the promises of God even though they didn’t live to see them fulfilled. Because of their faith, however, “God is not ashamed to be called their God, for He has prepared a city for them.” They will receive the reward for their faith and endurance. Even Noah became “an heir of the righteousness that is by faith.”
We know that they received the same message (as we’re told from Hebrews 4), and that, like us, they had to respond to it in faith. But how can those of the Old Testament have received the same message if Christ hadn’t come to earth in the Incarnation yet? Peter answers this superbly:
10 Concerning this salvation, the prophets (AB) who prophesied about the grace that would come to you searched and carefully investigated. 11 They inquired into what time or what circumstances [e] the Spirit of Christ (AC) within them was indicating when He testified in advance (AD) to the messianic sufferings (AE) [f] and the glories (AF) that would follow. [g] 12 It was revealed to them that they were not serving themselves but you concerning things that have now been announced to you through those who preached the gospel to you (AG) by the Holy Spirit sent from heaven. (1 Peter 1:10-12, HCSB)
The prophets had “the Spirit of Christ within them” when they prophesied of Christ’s sufferings and His glory. The Old Testament is full of references to Christ’s suffering and glory. For instance, there are the Suffering Servant passages of Isaiah 52-53. Psalm 22 is another regarding Christ’s sufferings. And Peter’s sermons in Acts are full of Old Testament prophecy concerning Christ. So within the Old Testament writers, the Spirit lived and used them to testify of Christ, the One who was to come.
In short, the Old Testament humanity heard the same message that we hear—except they heard of what was TO COME, we hear of what HAS ALREADY COME!
So when Spurgeon says that Christ couldn’t have died for all because of those who already died in their sins, I have to respond that those who died in wickedness made their choice—against God and His righteous standard. Their spending eternity in Hell, then, is the consequence of their choices.
To conclude this post, I would like to use some of the narrative of Luke 16 regarding the Parable of Lazarus and the Rich Man. The rich man lived in luxury, while Lazarus sat at the gate, eating crumbs and begging for mercy. But when the two died, Lazarus ended up in heaven while the rich man went to hell. The rich man, understanding how wrong he was, finally wants to help his relatives who are still alive:
27 " 'Father,' he said, 'then I beg you to send him to my father's house— 28 because I have five brothers—to warn (AL) them, so they won't also come to this place of torment.'
29 "But Abraham said, 'They have Moses and the prophets; (AM) they should listen to them.' (Luke 16:27-29, HCSB)
The Old Testament humanity had the prophets to listen to, who foretold of Christ and His suffering and glory. If that didn’t do it, nothing else would. Today we have those called by God to teach and preach the Word; if we don’t listen to the Word, then nothing else will do—even if someone should rise from the dead and tell us that it is all true.
Labels:
The Five Points of Calvinism
Spurgeon's Lapse, Part I
For the last few days, I’ve been reading “The Five Points of Calvinism: Defined, Defended, and Documented” by authors David N. Steele, Curtis C. Thomas, and S. Lance Quinn. The book is mostly composed of an explanation of each of the five tenets of Calvinism, followed by Scriptural justification. At the end of the book, however, are appendices. I read one of them tonight, called “A Defense of Calvinism” by the great preacher Charles Haddon Spurgeon. Spurgeon commits an “Arminian blunder” (an inconsistent Calvinist remark) when he writes the following:
“Then, in the fullness of time, He purchased me with His blood: He let His heart run out in one deep gaping wound for me, long ere I loved Him. Yea, WHEN HE FIRST CAME TO ME, DID I NOT SPURN HIM? When He knocked at the door, and ASKED for entrance, DID I NOT DRIVE HIM AWAY, AND DO DESPITE TO HIS GRACE? Ah, I CAN REMEMBER THAT I FULL OFTEN DID SO until, at last, by the power of HIS EFFECTUAL GRACE, He said, ‘I MUST, I WILL COME IN,’ and then HE TURNED MY HEART, AND MADE ME LOVE HIM” (Steele, Thomas, & Quinn, “The Five Points of Calvinism: Defined, Defended, and Documented.” Phillipsburg, New Jersey: P&R Publishing, 2004, page 175).
Spurgeon is telling here of just how he came to faith in Christ. Notice that he asks the question, “When He [Christ] first came to me, DID I NOT SPURN HIM?” Here is the definition of the word “spurn”:
intransitive verb 1 obsolete a : stumble b : kick 1a
2 archaic : to reject something disdainfully transitive verb 1 : to tread sharply or heavily upon : trample
2 : to reject with disdain or contempt : scorn
synonyms: decline
According to Merriam-Webster’s online dictionary (as quoted above), to “spurn” involves a rejection of something. And rejection is an open decision to NOT choose something. One chooses against it. As is clearly seen, choice is involved in rejection.
The next question of Spurgeon’s is, “When He knocked at the door, and ASKED FOR ENTRANCE, did I not DRIVE HIM AWAY and DO DESPITE TO HIS GRACE?”
The Lord knocked at the door of Spurgeon’s heart, and ASKED for entrance—He did not force Himself into Spurgeon’s heart. He did not break the door down; He simply opened it and asked that Spurgeon let Him in. This is the same thing a guest does. A guest does not kick the door in to gain entrance—he knocks and waits for the homeowner to open the door and allow entrance.
Here’s a definition of the word “ask”:
transitive verb 1 a : to call on for an answer b : to put a question about c : SPEAK, UTTER
2 a : to make a request of b : to make a request for
3 : to call for : REQUIRE
4 : to set as a price
5 : INVITEintransitive verb 1 : to seek information
2 : to make a request
3 : LOOK —often used in the phrase ask for trouble
There are a few definitions given by Merriam Webster here that I like most: “TO CALL for” and to “invite.” The Lord “calls” for all to come to Himself:
28 "Come to Me, all of you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest. (B) 29 All of you, take up My yoke and learn from Me, (C) because I am gentle and humble in heart, and you will find rest for yourselves. (Matthew 11:28-29, Holman Christian Standard Bible).
And the Lord did the same thing in the parable of the Wedding Banquet in Matthew 22:
8 "Then he told his slaves, 'The banquet is ready, but those who were invited were not worthy. (E) 9 Therefore, go to where the roads exit the city and invite everyone you find to the banquet. (F) ' 10 So those slaves went out on the roads and gathered everyone they found, both evil and good. The wedding banquet was filled with guests. (Matthew 22:8-10, HCSB).
Everyone the King’s servants could find was “invited” to the banquet. Notice that, earlier in the chapter, prior to verse 8, those who were “invited” to the banquet refused to come—all for various reasons. So there were guests invited who were allowed to REFUSE the invitation! No one was DRAGGED into the banquet unwillingly!
Spurgeon said that, when the Lord came to him and called him, he refused the invitation—he “drove Him away” and “did despite unto His grace.” The Lord knocked on the door of his heart for entrance; but, instead of knocking down the door, the Lord KNOCKED. And when He knocked, Spurgeon “answered the door” and “drove Him away,” sent the Lord packing. He told the Lord, “go away”—and went back inside. Not only did he drive the Lord away; he also “did despite to His grace.” What does this phrase mean?
I also looked up the word “despite” in Merriam-Webster’s Online Dictionary:
1: the feeling or attitude of despising : CONTEMPT 2: MALICE, SPITE 3 a: an act showing contempt or defiance b: DETRIMENT, DISADVANTAGE.
I like definition number 3a: “An act showing CONTEMPT or DEFIANCE.” When Spurgeon says that he “did despite to His grace,” this means that he trampled it, he “spat on it,” he cared nothing for it and wanted nothing of it. What does it mean to show “contempt”?
b: lack of respect or reverence for something2: the state of being despised3: willful disobedience to or open disrespect of a court, judge, or legislative body.
Definition 1b tells us that contempt is “lack of respect or reverence for something.” So when the Lord invited Spurgeon into His family, initially, he had no reverence for the Lord or His invitation. He was a bit like Pharaoh when Moses first went to him and told him the words of the Lord:
2 But Pharaoh responded, "Who is the LORD that I should obey Him by letting Israel go? I do not know the LORD, and what's more, I will not let Israel go." (Exodus 5:2, HCSB)
Pharaoh responded, “Who is the LORD…?” essentially, he was saying, “Who does the Lord think He is?” The name of the LORD didn’t even shock Pharaoh or cause him to tremble. And this was Spurgeon’s response when the Lord came knocking on the door of his heart.
But the last definition of the word “contempt” above is number 3—“WILLFUL DISOBEDIENCE to or OPEN DISRESPECT” of something. When a person is said to have WILLFUL DISOBEDIENCE, this indicates an inner intention to rebel against something. So the desire to rebel stems from the person; and the person is allowed to rebel. Spurgeon CHOSE to rebel.
However, he states that at one point, the Lord decides to get through to him and so “MADE me to love Him.” So the only way Spurgeon comes to Christ is that Christ “MAKES” Spurgeon come to Himself. The problem with Spurgeon’s assessment of his conversion is that, initially, he is allowed to REJECT the Spirit of Grace. Is Spurgeon saying that God allows the person to reject Him, and “kick” against Him? I think he is.
This what makes the Calvinist assessment so hard to reconcile: when mankind is in sin, he does what HE DESIRES to do; but, when he accepts Christ, now the Lord MAKES HIM do what the Lord wants him to do! If the person can do what he desires before Christ, why can’t he do what Christ desires AFTER CHRIST? The Calvinist acknowledges that man does his own thing BEFORE CHRIST; but at the moment of conversion and after Christ, the Spirit FORCES people to do things, MAKES them confess their sins, and MAKES them do His bidding.
Spurgeon’s lapse in his “Defense” is that he actually recalls a time when he rebelled against the Lord’s plea to be saved. In the Calvinist system, however, God is not one who KNOCKS, but one who INVADES and PLUNDERS!
I will cover more on Spurgeon’s Lapse in my next post.
“Then, in the fullness of time, He purchased me with His blood: He let His heart run out in one deep gaping wound for me, long ere I loved Him. Yea, WHEN HE FIRST CAME TO ME, DID I NOT SPURN HIM? When He knocked at the door, and ASKED for entrance, DID I NOT DRIVE HIM AWAY, AND DO DESPITE TO HIS GRACE? Ah, I CAN REMEMBER THAT I FULL OFTEN DID SO until, at last, by the power of HIS EFFECTUAL GRACE, He said, ‘I MUST, I WILL COME IN,’ and then HE TURNED MY HEART, AND MADE ME LOVE HIM” (Steele, Thomas, & Quinn, “The Five Points of Calvinism: Defined, Defended, and Documented.” Phillipsburg, New Jersey: P&R Publishing, 2004, page 175).
Spurgeon is telling here of just how he came to faith in Christ. Notice that he asks the question, “When He [Christ] first came to me, DID I NOT SPURN HIM?” Here is the definition of the word “spurn”:
intransitive verb 1 obsolete a : stumble b : kick 1a
2 archaic : to reject something disdainfully transitive verb 1 : to tread sharply or heavily upon : trample
2 : to reject with disdain or contempt : scorn
synonyms: decline
According to Merriam-Webster’s online dictionary (as quoted above), to “spurn” involves a rejection of something. And rejection is an open decision to NOT choose something. One chooses against it. As is clearly seen, choice is involved in rejection.
The next question of Spurgeon’s is, “When He knocked at the door, and ASKED FOR ENTRANCE, did I not DRIVE HIM AWAY and DO DESPITE TO HIS GRACE?”
The Lord knocked at the door of Spurgeon’s heart, and ASKED for entrance—He did not force Himself into Spurgeon’s heart. He did not break the door down; He simply opened it and asked that Spurgeon let Him in. This is the same thing a guest does. A guest does not kick the door in to gain entrance—he knocks and waits for the homeowner to open the door and allow entrance.
Here’s a definition of the word “ask”:
transitive verb 1 a : to call on for an answer
2 a : to make a request of
3 : to call for : REQUIRE
4 : to set as a price
5 : INVITEintransitive verb 1 : to seek information
2 : to make a request
3 : LOOK —often used in the phrase ask for trouble
There are a few definitions given by Merriam Webster here that I like most: “TO CALL for” and to “invite.” The Lord “calls” for all to come to Himself:
28 "Come to Me, all of you who are weary and burdened, and I will give you rest. (B) 29 All of you, take up My yoke and learn from Me, (C) because I am gentle and humble in heart, and you will find rest for yourselves. (Matthew 11:28-29, Holman Christian Standard Bible).
And the Lord did the same thing in the parable of the Wedding Banquet in Matthew 22:
8 "Then he told his slaves, 'The banquet is ready, but those who were invited were not worthy. (E) 9 Therefore, go to where the roads exit the city and invite everyone you find to the banquet. (F) ' 10 So those slaves went out on the roads and gathered everyone they found, both evil and good. The wedding banquet was filled with guests. (Matthew 22:8-10, HCSB).
Everyone the King’s servants could find was “invited” to the banquet. Notice that, earlier in the chapter, prior to verse 8, those who were “invited” to the banquet refused to come—all for various reasons. So there were guests invited who were allowed to REFUSE the invitation! No one was DRAGGED into the banquet unwillingly!
Spurgeon said that, when the Lord came to him and called him, he refused the invitation—he “drove Him away” and “did despite unto His grace.” The Lord knocked on the door of his heart for entrance; but, instead of knocking down the door, the Lord KNOCKED. And when He knocked, Spurgeon “answered the door” and “drove Him away,” sent the Lord packing. He told the Lord, “go away”—and went back inside. Not only did he drive the Lord away; he also “did despite to His grace.” What does this phrase mean?
I also looked up the word “despite” in Merriam-Webster’s Online Dictionary:
1: the feeling or attitude of despising : CONTEMPT 2: MALICE, SPITE 3 a: an act showing contempt or defiance b: DETRIMENT, DISADVANTAGE.
I like definition number 3a: “An act showing CONTEMPT or DEFIANCE.” When Spurgeon says that he “did despite to His grace,” this means that he trampled it, he “spat on it,” he cared nothing for it and wanted nothing of it. What does it mean to show “contempt”?
b: lack of respect or reverence for something2: the state of being despised3: willful disobedience to or open disrespect of a court, judge, or legislative body.
Definition 1b tells us that contempt is “lack of respect or reverence for something.” So when the Lord invited Spurgeon into His family, initially, he had no reverence for the Lord or His invitation. He was a bit like Pharaoh when Moses first went to him and told him the words of the Lord:
2 But Pharaoh responded, "Who is the LORD that I should obey Him by letting Israel go? I do not know the LORD, and what's more, I will not let Israel go." (Exodus 5:2, HCSB)
Pharaoh responded, “Who is the LORD…?” essentially, he was saying, “Who does the Lord think He is?” The name of the LORD didn’t even shock Pharaoh or cause him to tremble. And this was Spurgeon’s response when the Lord came knocking on the door of his heart.
But the last definition of the word “contempt” above is number 3—“WILLFUL DISOBEDIENCE to or OPEN DISRESPECT” of something. When a person is said to have WILLFUL DISOBEDIENCE, this indicates an inner intention to rebel against something. So the desire to rebel stems from the person; and the person is allowed to rebel. Spurgeon CHOSE to rebel.
However, he states that at one point, the Lord decides to get through to him and so “MADE me to love Him.” So the only way Spurgeon comes to Christ is that Christ “MAKES” Spurgeon come to Himself. The problem with Spurgeon’s assessment of his conversion is that, initially, he is allowed to REJECT the Spirit of Grace. Is Spurgeon saying that God allows the person to reject Him, and “kick” against Him? I think he is.
This what makes the Calvinist assessment so hard to reconcile: when mankind is in sin, he does what HE DESIRES to do; but, when he accepts Christ, now the Lord MAKES HIM do what the Lord wants him to do! If the person can do what he desires before Christ, why can’t he do what Christ desires AFTER CHRIST? The Calvinist acknowledges that man does his own thing BEFORE CHRIST; but at the moment of conversion and after Christ, the Spirit FORCES people to do things, MAKES them confess their sins, and MAKES them do His bidding.
Spurgeon’s lapse in his “Defense” is that he actually recalls a time when he rebelled against the Lord’s plea to be saved. In the Calvinist system, however, God is not one who KNOCKS, but one who INVADES and PLUNDERS!
I will cover more on Spurgeon’s Lapse in my next post.
Labels:
The Five Points of Calvinism
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)