Showing posts with label The Historical Jesus. Show all posts
Showing posts with label The Historical Jesus. Show all posts

Thursday, August 11, 2011

"Many Convincing Proofs": The Signs of The Resurrection

  Throughout this series on Reformed Epistemology, I have aimed to present Dr. Plantinga’s presentation of RE in a fair manner. Though I am imperfect, and could easily misrepresent others due to the depravity of man and the Fall, I have aimed to represent RE accurately. I pray that my labor has resulted in blessing, for both those who agree with me and those who disagree.

One of the weaknesses of RE (in my estimation) is that the system claims that one need neither evidence nor argument to be deemed rational for theistic belief. I have pointed out that this argument aims to preserve the truth of Christianity while eliminating the dependence of the truth on evidence; what really happens, though, is that, by severing evidence and argument from truth, one allows that which is irrational to be true (since evidence nor argument is needed for something to be true). This does not seem right. The truth is always confirmed by the evidence...but to allow Christians to be rational in their faith (though there is no evidence) is to make Christians appear “illogical” in their faith. If Christianity is true (and I believe it is), Paul does not lie when he states that God’s invisible attributes (His eternal power and Godhead) have been displayed in “the things that have been made” (Rom. 1:18-20). Since God has revealed Himself, the truth and the evidence will always corroborate, not oppose, each other.

In today’s post, I will cover Jesus’ work post-resurrection: that is, His signs He gave His followers to demonstrate that He had really risen from the dead. The purpose of this post is to examine the numerous proofs Jesus gave...and thereby display our Lord’s willingness to provide tangible proof of His resurrection (despite the truth of the claims He made). Our Lord did not “risk” the truth of His claims; He simply confirmed the truth of them.

To begin this post, let’s look at Luke’s words about Jesus in his prologue to the book of Acts:

“The first account I composed, Theophilus, about all that Jesus began to do and teach, until the day when He was taken up to heaven, after He had by the Holy Spirit given orders to the apostles whom He had chosen. To these He also presented Himself alive after His suffering, by many convincing proofs, appearing to them over a period of forty days and speaking of the things concerning the kingdom of God” (Acts 1:1-3, NASB).

When most people read about the life of Christ, they turn to the gospels; but how many people turn to Acts 1 when reading of the life of Christ? Very few. And in the Acts prologue lies some very useful information we would not have without it. First, notice that Luke’s gospel was nothing more than “all that Jesus began to do and teach” (Acts 1:1). It was not all Jesus did and taught...rather, the work of Christ in the gospels was only the beginning of Jesus’ ministry. And why? Because the Spirit would continue the work of Christ. As Jesus Himself said, “but when He, the Spirit of truth, come, He will guide you into all truth...He will glorify Me, for He will take of Mine and will disclose it to you” (John 16:13-14). In other words, the Spirit would take what Jesus taught and teach it to believers.

Acts 1:3 tells us that it is to the apostles that He showed Himself to have risen from the dead. The Greek word for “convincing,” tekmerion, refers to “that from which something is surely and plainly known on indubitable evidence, a proof” (http://www.biblestudytools.com/lexicons/greek/nas/tekmerion.html). The word tekmerion is only used once in the New Testament. What Luke says here is that Jesus provided indisputable evidence of His resurrection to the disciples, such that they found it too hard to disbelieve.

In today’s post, I desire to investigate some of the proof Jesus’ provided to make the case that He had risen from the dead. One such proof is found in John 20, where Jesus first appears to the disciples after His resurrection:

“So when it was evening on that day, the first day of the week, and when the doors were shut were the disciples were, for fear of the Jews, Jesus came and stood in their midst and said to them, ‘Peace be with you.’ And when He had said this, He showed them both His hands and His side. The disciples then rejoiced when they saw the Lord” (John 20:19-20, NASB).

What is significant about this moment in John’s chapter is that the text tells us the disciples secluded themselves “for fear of the Jews.” Since they had been with Jesus, they feared what the Jews would do to them. If the Jews crucified Jesus, and the disciples had been with Him, then the disciples feared the Jews would crucify them, perhaps.

And it is in the midst of this fear that Jesus comes to them to show that He had risen. What does He show them when He comes? “both His hands and His side.” He showed His hands because He had nail scars in them from the cross; He showed His side because He had been pierced in His side and they saw both blood and water streaming down. And the moment they see these physical proofs, they “rejoiced when they saw the Lord.” In other words, seeing these physical proofs, the disciples knew that it was Jesus standing among them.

Doubting Thomas (as he is always infamously known) was not with them; but when he returned to the disciples’ company, the disciples told him that they had seen Jesus, to which he responded negatively (see John 20:25). Eight days later, Jesus reappears to the disciples (this time, Thomas is among them), and says the same thing He said to the disciples (minus Thomas) the first time. Knowing Thomas’s statement (“unless I see in His hands the imprint of the nails, and put my finger into the place of the nails, and put my hand into His side, I will not believe”, Jn. 20:26), Jesus tells Thomas, “Reach here with your finger, and see My hands; and reach here your hand and put it into My side; and do not be unbelieving, but believing” (Jn. 20:27).

Why does Jesus allow Thomas to feel the places where there were scars? Because without it, Thomas refused to believe. Jesus’ words to Thomas in verse 29 have been used to make the case that faith is more important than evidence:

“No doubt there is more than one point here [John 20:29]; a central point, surely, is that those who have been given faith are indeed blessed. Their faith is a gift requiring joyful thanksgiving, not a moral lapse requiring shamefaced repentance. One who has faith, therefore, is (or may very well be) justified according to the model” (Dr. Alvin Plantinga, Warranted Christian Belief. New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press, 2000, pages 254-255).

True, faith is not a “moral lapse”...but faith is a moral lapse if it does not involve reasoning and evidence. Faith in and of itself is not a moral lapse...but blind faith is. And Jesus did not ask the disciples to have blind evidence. Remember, He showed His scars to the disciples (minus Thomas) in John 20:20). He said what He did to Thomas because Thomas required absolute evidence. For Thomas, he needed more evidence than the other disciples in order to believe. Jesus’ point to Thomas was that those who need absolute evidence will never find what they seek. Rather, one must believe that the evidence that is presented is true, even thought it may be only a small portion. Even when the evidence is presented, one must have faith and accept what is presented as true. If one requires absolute proof of the truth, then one will never find it. Luke, of course, calls the evidence Jesus presented as “convincing” because it could not be disputed. If I saw someone who died, now appeared to be alive from the dead, and had nail scars in His hands and feet and piercing in His side to prove He was the one who had died, I would believe, too!

No one on earth is placed in a state where they are told to believe in the absence of evidence. Though Jesus is in heaven today, and though we did not live in the time of the disciples, we still have substantial evidence today that testifies to the resurrection of Jesus...including the testimony of the disciples themselves in the Scriptures. And if something happened today, like a shooting or a robbery or a hurricane event, to find out what happened we would talk to those who experienced it...and unless we discovered the witnesses were really liars, we would assume it to be true. Unfortunately, we live in a world where lots of people lie for personal reasons...but then, we have the evidence. The tangible, physical evidence will point us to the truth. If someone says he was shot (for example), but shot himself, all we need to do is get forensics experts on the case. The evidence doesn’t lie. It didn’t lie for the disciples in the face of Jesus, and it does not lie today. I will talk more about the “many convincing proofs” in my next post. Stay tuned...

Thursday, July 7, 2011

The Bible in Context: Dr. Bart Ehrman and the Doctrine of Inerrancy


Before I get started, let me just say that it’s a blessing to be able to return to the Center for Theological Studies. I have had a unique summer, writing daily for some time, only to stop and resort to reading. I’ve spent the last several days catching up on sleep and trying to pamper my body after beating it up for about five months straight (I call this “Spring semester”...smile!). In order to write strong, a theologian sometimes needs to sleep as strongly. The last several days have been a good example of this. Needless to say, I have still been reading and keeping my mind sharp. I think my mentor would almost try to arrest me if I didn’t (Dr. Keathley, I know you wouldn’t...just kidding).

Recently, I got the opportunity to watch a few debates online at Youtube. I highly recommend the site for those who love good debates. Call it the apologist in me, but I love to see Christians debate atheists...particularly when William Lane Craig will debate an evolutionist. There are some good debates of his on Youtube; the ones I saw recently are his debate against Dr. John Shook. I actually laughed at Richard Dawkins’s response to the question of why he would not debate William Lane Craig. His response was not sufficient at all...but it goes to show believers just how scared atheists become when we engage the world via the human intellect. With our God-given minds, we can literally make the world speechless before our God!!!

In today’s post, however, I intend to discuss the William Lane Craig debate against Bart D. Ehrman. For those who may not know, William Lane Craig is a professor out at Biola University as well as a Christian apologist and author; famous among his books is Reasonable Faith: Christian Truth and Apologetics, Third Edition. He is also the author of The Only Wise God: The Compatibility of Divine Foreknowledge and Human Freedom. Dr. Craig often defends the Classical approach to apologetics and is a heavyweight on the subject.

To counter him, there is Dr. Bart D. Ehrman, James A. Gray Distinguished Professor of Religious Studies at the University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill. Dr. Ehrman, for those who may not know, is a former professor of mine. I sat under him in his well-known “New Testament Literature” class, back in Spring 2003. It was Dr. Ehrman that influenced me (indirectly) to attend seminary right after college. Upon my arrival at Southeastern Seminary in August 2006, I met former classmates of mine from Carolina who were also influenced in Dr. Ehrman’s class to attend seminary to learn how to defend the faith. Unbeknownst to Dr. Ehrman, my fellow seminarians and I are here at Southeastern because God used him to push us in the right direction. I like to think of what happened with my friends and me as a “God-using-King-Cyrus-to-free-the-Israelites” sort of thing.

In any case, watching the Youtube debate between Dr. Craig and Dr. Ehrman was an entertaining one indeed (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FhT4IENSwac). Of course, Dr. Ehrman’s usual argument consists of the statement, “The Bible contains errors, inconsistencies, and contradictions.” All throughout the debate, this is the Ehrman cry. In fact, I recently saw Dr. Ehrman debate Dr. Craig Evans (professor from Acadia Divinity in Nova Scotia) in New Orleans this past February 2011. He said the exact same thing.

Unfortunately, Dr. Craig did not answer Dr. Ehrman’s questions regarding inerrancy. Craig’s remark (an extremely brilliant one indeed) was, “Inerrancy is not the subject of tonight’s debate.” Still, though, I think we should answer the question of inerrancy because everything rides on inerrancy. If the Bible is not inerrant, if the Bible contains errors, then the Bible could be wrong on salvation (and thus loses its infallibility). As a result everything else crumbles. If the Bible is wrong in one part, why should we believe any of it? This is no small matter indeed...and Christians have gotta learn to step up to the plate and defend what we believe. The time to smile and be passive is long gone. A new millennium now awaits us. The task of apologetics is before us.

After watching the debate, I decided to do a little reading on the subject...so I picked up Dr. Norman Geisler’s edited work titled Inerrancy. The work has great chapters on the apostles and inerrancy, Jesus and inerrancy, the doctrine of inerrancy as upheld by the church fathers, tackling the supposed “errors” that atheists have claimed the Bible possesses, not to mention the Chicago Statement on Inerrancy in the appendix. I have not provided all the chapters in this work, but I highly suggest you buy it. Every Christian ought to have at least one book on inerrancy on their bookshelf.

 These words of the Chicago Statement provide for me the response to Dr. Ehrman’s claim that the Bible contains “errors, inconsistencies, and contradictions.” In one paragraph, the writers of the Chicago Statement tie inerrancy to the sovereignty of God:

“We affirm that canonical Scripture should always be interpreted on the basis that it is infallible and inerrant. However, in determining what the God-taught writer is asserting in each passage, we must pay the most careful attention to its claims and character as a human production. In inspiration, God utilized the culture and conventions of his penman’s milieu, a milieu that God controls in His sovereign providence; it is misinterpretation to imagine otherwise” (Chicago Statement, printed in Inerrancy by Dr. Norman Geisler, editor. Grand Rapids: Zondervan, 1980, page 500).

The first statement underlined above is one that I think is often missed in the debate on inerrancy: that is, the statement that discusses “milieu,” what I call “context.” Dr. Craig did not respond like the above quote from the Chicago Statement...but I think this proves most fatal to Dr. Ehrman’s position. If God used the conventions of the first century to produce the New Testament, then we must find the reason behind why the writers wrote the things they did. One of the most basic principles one will hear the first day of the seminary Hermeneutics class is, “A text means what it means in its context.” That is, a passage must first be interpreted in its context before one can give the text an appropriate, contemporary interpretation. If the Old and New Testaments have context, then the entire Bible does...which means that one cannot approach the text with twenty-first-century lenses without examining the text with first-century lenses first.

When we do, we find that the writers must be assessed on the conventions (historical, literary, artistic, etc.) of their day. When Dr. Ehrman says, “The Bible has errors, inconsistencies, and contradictions,” he is applying a modern-day notion of these terms. His approach to the Bible would be the same thing as if I accused Geoffrey Chaucer of “misspelling” a word in his Canterbury Tales, where he may have written “signe” instead of “sign.” Today’s spelling of the word may be “sign,” but there very well may have been (in his day) the spelling of “signe” or “syne.” I simply cannot overlook Chaucer’s context (Middle English) when assessing his work. The same can be said of assessing the Bible on its own terms.

The Chicago writers continue to hammer home respect for conventions and context in the Statement:

“Differences between literary conventions in Bible times and in ours must also be observed; since, for instance, non-chronological narration and imprecise citation were conventional and acceptable and violated no expectations in those days, we must not regard these things as faults when we find them in Bible writers. When total precision of a particular kind was not expected nor aimed at, it is no error not to have achieved it” (Chicago Statement, Inerrancy, page 500).

Non-chronological narration is also attacked, as well as rounded numbers and so forth. But, once again, if these were acceptable conventions of the day, why should they be labeled “errors” or “inconsistencies”? In order for someone to label statements as errors, there must be something to compare or place beside the statements. What is that ruler or measure of comparison, one may ask? Modern standards of notation! But, did these exist in the Bible days? No. How, then, can one anachronistically place the Bible outside of its time and label it an error? This goes against how we assess other documents, literary works, and statements. And I think to do this to only the Bible (while leaving other works such as Plato’s “Republic” or Chaucer’s “Canterbury Tales” unscathed) is a heresy and a travesty to proper thought.

We cannot take a work out of its time and make it fit the conventions of our day. Neither can we take a modern-day work and make it fit the conventions of an earlier time. As the Chicago writers stated, God, in His sovereignty, utilized the literary and historical conventions of Jesus’ day. So, in order to label the four Gospels, for example, as “erroneous,” one must find the literary conventions of the first century, then measure the four Gospels beside those conventions. And until Dr. Ehrman does this, the supposed “debate” is really no debate at all...much ado about nothing. God bless.

Tuesday, March 8, 2011

The Gospel of John and The Problem of the Historical Jesus: Reflections From the Greer-Heard Conference, Pt. III

It has been some time ago since I wrote on John and the problem of the historical Jesus. I interrupted the series yesterday with a most blessed announcement...so today, I will get back to my work on the problem of the historical Jesus.
In the last post, I tried to establish the apostle John’s integrity in that he records Jesus’ actual sayings and doings. To state that the things John records are not true is to make ourselves eyewitnesses of the Lord Jesus (which we are not). We have no more truth about the facts of Jesus than John; in fact, we have very little when compared to John. He is one who actually saw Jesus in the flesh (1 Jn. 1:1-2). In addition, the Johannine community seems to affirm that John’s sayings are true (Gospel of John 21: 24). Were you and I eyewitnesses to the life, death, and resurrection of Christ? No. Since we were not, we cannot presume to know more than the apostle John. What we have to do is allow the apostle John to tell his own story without presuming that our twenty-first-century way of thinking is better and “more accurate” than John’s was in the first century. But of course, that presumes that we would actually allow the text to speak for itself. God forbid that day should come...?
I believe that John’s Gospel is “worthy of all acceptation,” to use a phrase of Andrew Fuller’s; today’s post, however, will look at support for John’s work in the biblical canon: that is, John will be supported by the writings of the apostle Paul. To Paul, the life, death, and resurrection of Christ happened as the Old Testament Scriptures said they would. Paul wrote 1 Corinthians somewhere between 53-55 AD. The Gospel of John is placed somewhere between 50-70 AD, with great consensus on the 60s AD as the decade of John’s writing. If such information is correct, then Paul clearly wrote his letter to the Corinthians before John’s Gospel was compiled...which means that Paul could serve as a valid source for the historical Jesus in addition to John. Paul’s writing was not discussed at the Greer-Heard Conference, but I think it should have been. The debate was rather stacked by the debaters themselves when only John’s Gospel was mentioned. It basically made the Gospel of John look as if it was out on a limb all by itself.
In today’s post, then, I will tackle Paul’s work on the historical Jesus via 1 Corinthians 15, a passage where Paul justifies the life, death, and resurrection of Christ. It is important that Paul shows that Jesus really lived and died. However, it is not Christ’s humanity that is denied in the Gospel of John; rather, it is Christ’s deity, Christ’s divinity, that is questioned. Paul writes to show that Christ’s divinity must be true as well---or else, Christianity is a flop.
In 1 Corinthians 15:3, Paul writes that “I delivered to you first of all that which I also received,” stating that he himself was taught the facts about Christ. That’s right---the events Paul records are not up for negotiation as to whether they happened or not...rather, they did happen. In verse 3, Paul states that Christ “died for our sins according to the Scriptures.” What are the “Scriptures” he speaks of here? The Scriptures Paul references are the writings of the Old Testament concerning Jesus. Paul alerts us, if we have missed it throughout the New Testament up to this point, that the Old Testament foretold of the Incarnation (where Jesus would take upon Himself human flesh).
In verse 4, Christ not only died, but was buried and was resurrected on the third day, “according to the Scriptures.” The Old Testament also confirmed Christ’s burial and resurrection. A good text that comes to mind regarding the life of Christ that clearly shows the Messianic mission is Isaiah 53:
“He was cut off from the land of the living; for the transgressions of My people He was stricken. And they made His grave with the wicked---but with the rich at His death, because He had done no violence, nor was any deceit in His mouth. Yet it pleased the Lord to bruise Him; He has put Him to grief. When You make His soul an offering for sin...” (Isaiah 53:8b-10a, NKJV)
Isaiah goes on to say more:
“He shall divide the spoil with the strong, because He poured out His soul unto death, and He was numbered with the transgressors, and He bore the sin of many, and made intercession for the transgressors” (Isa. 53:12b).
Paul validates the Old Testament concerning Christ. Since he himself had been a Pharisee, well-educated in the Hebrew Scriptures (Old Testament), he was qualified to make such a statement: that Christ’s life, death, burial, and resurrection took place “according to the Scriptures.”
But Paul does not stop there. He not only says that the Old Testament prophesied the events of Christ’s life, but that the events had eyewitness testimony: “and that He was seen by Cephas, then by the twelve” (1 Cor. 15:5). Jesus appeared to the men He had chosen to follow Him. In verse 6, Paul says that “He was seen by over five-hundred brethren at once, of whom the greater part remain to the present, but some have fallen asleep.” What did Paul mean by this statement? Some eyewitnesses have died, but there are many who are still alive!!! The significance of such a statement is, “If you think I’m deceiving you, go check with these men...they are still around to support what I’m telling you.” The apostle John would have been one of these who was still alive at the time. From what we know, John lived to be a ripe old age and enjoyed being an elder in the church until his death. The apostle would have been one of those who could serve as a reliable eyewitness to the events that Paul recorded.
Isn’t that interesting? Paul wrote his letter to the Corinthians before John wrote his Gospel...but John could serve as reliable testimony, in the eyes of Paul. And if Paul could validate John’s testimony as an eyewitness, does Paul not validate John’s Gospel, written after his Corinthian letter? Even though Paul himself wrote about 20 years after the death and resurrection of Christ (53-55 AD, Christ died around 30-33), he believed that the living eyewitnesses could validate the events in his letter; that is, that the mental faculties (memory especially) of the eyewitnesses was still sharp enough to recall the moment they looked upon the risen Christ. Unlike many skeptical scholars and historians today, Paul didn’t think the eyewitnesses were hallucinating!
In verse 7, Paul notes that James (Jesus’ half-brother) and other apostles in the early church got to see the risen Christ as well. And in verse 8, he says that he himself saw the risen Christ, an account that we have preserved in the biblical canon itself (Acts 9:1-22; 22:1-21).
Now someone could easily say, “Paul is validating John because he met with John to talk about the risen Christ, right? After all, Paul collaborated with the apostles regarding what he had seen and heard.” A skeptic could easily dismiss Paul’s testimony by saying that the apostles told him what he saw and “brushed up” his story a bit. However, to think such a thing actually contradicts what Luke writes:
“And when Saul had come to Jerusalem, he tried to join the disciples; but they were all afraid of him, and did not believe that he was a disciple. But Barnabas took him and brought him to the disciples. And he declared to them how he had seen the Lord on the road, and that He had spoken to Him, and how he had preached boldly at Damascus in the name of Jesus” (Acts 9:26-27).
When Paul meets the disciples, he had already begun preaching the gospel of the risen Christ in Damascus. His preaching and revelation, then, were given INDEPENDENTLY of the disciples. A case for independent attestation is made here with Paul and the disciples...
And this also contradicts what Paul writes about his own experience. Paul says that after seeing the risen Christ,
“I did not immediately confer with flesh and blood, nor did I go up to Jerusalem to those who were apostles before me; but I went to Arabia, and returned again to Damascus. THEN AFTER THREE YEARS I went up to Jerusalem to see Peter, and remained with him fifteen days” (Galatians 1:16-18).
Paul spends three years in the desert of Arabia before meeting with the first apostle. This is clear testimony of independent attestation. Paul uses this to prove that he is a legitimate apostle and eyewitness of the risen Christ because he received the revelation from Christ Himself, not from any human.
Today’s post was to validate the apostle John’s eyewitness testimony by using the testimony of the apostle Paul. The fact that Paul went alone to preach in Damascus and to spend three years in the desert of Arabia after the Christ revelation demonstrates that his testimony was not “propped” or “created” after corroboration, but rather was a genuine revelation from the Divine Himself. And if Paul could write 1 Corinthians 15 and validate the eyewitnesses (both dead and living) of Christ, then surely, the apostle John’s testimony is valid and true. John was one of the Twelve, and the first to see the risen Lord; consequently, he surely could not have falsified such testimony...considering also that many others saw the risen Christ as well. Stay tuned...

Tuesday, March 1, 2011

The Gospel of John and the Problem of the Historical Jesus: Reflections From the Greer-Heard Conference, Pt. II

Yesterday I posted my opening responses to Drs. Craig Evans and Bart Ehrman regarding the debate on the historical Jesus. As I made clear yesterday, Dr. Ehrman did not meet opposition in his claims about the Gospels; rather, he met agreement. Dr. Craig Evans, the evangelical scholar, agreed with Bart Ehrman that the words Jesus is reported to have said in John were not actually spoken by Christ. I’ll place my paraphrase of Evans’s words here once more:
“In Proverbs,” he asked, “Does not Lady Wisdom speak truth? Yes she does. But is there an actual Lady Wisdom speaking truth here? Do these events literally happen? No. Rather, the emphasis is not on what literally happened, but the truth that was spoken. When you come to the Gospel of John, Jesus is representing Lady Wisdom here, speaking truth. Remember what John says about Christ, that He is ‘the Logos’ (the Word)?”
I asserted that Evans left the conclusion of his thought open to his hearers. Instead of actually saying, “Jesus did not speak the words He is given in John,” rather, he simply stated that Jesus was like the Lady Wisdom of Proverbs (and left it to his hearers to decide what exactly that statement meant). If I heard Dr. Evans right, Jesus did not speak the words of John.
And this has problems for the Scriptures and Christianity. If Evans is right, then statements such as “I am the resurrection and the life” (Jn. 11:25) and “I am the way, the truth, and the life” (Jn. 14:6) were not really spoken by Jesus. And if such statements were not spoken by Jesus, then how can we know whether or not they are true? Evans’s only response was that such statements are “the Johannine community’s affirmations about Jesus”; but, if such statements are not based on actual statements of Christ Himself, how can we know if they should be believed or not? One could say, “Well, just believe the Johannine community”...but if the Johannine community can invent things that we all should believe, then I can say things here that are historically inaccurate, and all who read my words should believe me. When I say that I have three PhDs and over 25 years of experience in theological research, everyone who reads my words should believe me. But to believe me, you would be deceived---for the truth is, I haven’t been researching for 25 years and I don’t have three PhDs. In the same way one can test out whether or not I’m telling the truth, there must be some grounds for the community’s affirmation of Jesus. If the community simply invented these things to “deify” Jesus, then why should the twenty-first-century Christian community believe anything the Gospels themselves tell us? How could we know, in such a case, that all of the information isn’t simply “made up”?
And there was no answer given to this. Rather, Evans concluded his words on Saturday with, “Investigate the truth for yourself...research in this area and be open-minded to the evidence...go where the evidence leads you.” It appears that, if we take Evans’s words, we should all “go where the evidence” led him: to deny that Jesus actually said what John records He said.
Not only does Evans’s affirmation pose problems for Christianity, it also poses problems for the Scriptures. The idea of a Johannine community affirming things about Jesus that Jesus didn’t say does as well, but more importantly, Evans’s affirmation leads one to deny the very text itself on the issue of the historical Jesus. These are John’s concluding remarks about his Gospel:
“This is the disciple who testifies of these things, and wrote these things; and we know that his testimony is true. And there are also MANY OTHER THINGS THAT JESUS DID, which if they were written one by one, I suppose that even the world itself could not contain the books that would be written. Amen” (John 21:24-25, NKJV).
Now, in this text we see that there is John (“the disciple who testifies of these things”) and a Johannine community (“and we know that his testimony is true”). It seems as if John gave an account that has been validated by the community in John’s Gospel. In other words, the community believes precisely the way they do because of John’s own words. Evidently, Evans has never read the end of John; for the Johannine community’s affirmations of Jesus are based on the eyewitness account of the Apostle John. To say that Jesus’s words are just “the Johannine community’s affirmations” is proven wrong simply by the end of John 21.
To make matters worse, what about the community’s affirmation that “we know that his testimony is true”? The Johannine community assumed that John’s words were true. To say that Jesus’ words as recorded in John were not spoken by Jesus is to say that John’s testimony is “false.” To be honest, I would rather believe John the eyewitness than Craig Evans or any other modern scholar who stands in the twenty-first century. I think it is theological snobbery to assume that John was hallucinating or using his freedom to write about Christ simply to "plant" things in Christ’s mouth that He never said.
To put the nail on the coffin, what about the words that “there are many other things Jesus did”? If there are “other things” that are not recorded in John that Jesus did, what does this imply about the recorded sayings and events? That Jesus ACTUALLY DID THEM, that such recorded events are true! Once again, if John is saying that such events happened, then to say (like Craig Evans) that such events did not happen is to contradict the Scriptures themselves. After all, if the sayings of Christ never took place, then how can John have called on the readers to believe in a Christ whose deeds John himself falsified? How could John and the Johannine community have labeled something “true” that was “false”? How could they call on the reader (then and today) to believe something that was “false”? How could they say “and we KNOW that his testimony is true” when knowledge is a “justified TRUE belief,” not just a justified belief? This is what is problematic about Evans’s affirmation: that he would stand up publicly and deny Jesus’ statements about Himself (and thus, discredit the witness of the Apostle John who actually walked and communed with Christ in His ministry). Who is right: the Apostle John or Dr. Craig Evans? That is something I will leave to you, the reader, to decide.
In this post, I have examined Craig Evans’s words regarding the Gospel of John and the problem of the historical Jesus. I have concluded that Evans’s words contradict the Scriptures and the genuine truthfulness of John (who claims to be an eyewitness) as well as the Johannine community (who based their claims on the truth claims of the Apostle John). Craig Evans says that Jesus never spoke the words John says he did and that the community themselves simply affirmed things they had no evidence for. By so doing, he is denying the inerrancy, infallibility, and inspiration of Scripture: inerrancy and infallibility because the Scriptures are assumed to contain no error...inspiration because all of Scripture is “God-breathed” (2 Tim. 3:16). I will tackle more regarding the Greer-Heard Conference in coming posts.



Monday, February 28, 2011

The Gospel of John and the Problem of the Historical Jesus: Reflections from the Greer-Heard Conference

I am back from the Greer-Heard Conference, which was held at New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary in New Orleans, Louisiana, this past weekend (February 25-26, 2011). There was much discussion in the forums and presentations, but the object of attention was the debate on the historical Jesus, between Dr. Craig Evans of Acadia Divinity College and Dr. Bart D. Ehrman, James A. Gray Distinguished Professor of Religious Studies and the Chair of the Religious Studies Program at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. The debate was held on Friday night, February 25, 2011, at 7:00pm in Leavell Chapel (on the New Orleans Seminary campus).
Dr. Ehrman was allowed to speak first. His opening statements on the Scriptures themselves were magnificent. While listening to him, I was reminded of how captivating of a professor he really was, reminiscing over my own New Testament Literature class with him at the University of North Carolina back in Spring 2003. Line by line, Dr. Ehrman pointed out what he believed to be “historical discrepancies” in each of the four Gospels. For instance, he noted how one Gospel has Jesus dying on the cross during the week of Passover...while another has Jesus dying after Passover. “Which is it?” he asked. “They both cannot be right.” By the end of his opening statements, I got the distinct impression that defeating him would be a tall order.
And indeed, a tall order it was. In fact, it was such a tall order that I don’t even think Craig Evans came close to meeting it. Evans’s opening statement did not even respond to Ehrman’s claims. Instead, Evans simply tried to make a connection between the Bible and other works of antiquity: how the works of antiquity were written hundreds of years after the individuals lived and yet, they were still accepted as historical sources. When compared to these ancient works, the Gospels (according to Evans) had a rather outstanding record: the Gospels themselves were written no later than 35-40 years after the death of Christ. His argument was a lesser-to-greater: if the ancient sources were historically credible, having been written some hundreds of years after the events they record, then how much more historically reliable are the Gospels?
But what this really does is attempt to create “damage control.” Damage control is a tactic used to make something seem better than it may be portrayed as being. In fact, Evans’s remarks were pointed at the sole purpose of making the Gospels seem “less historically questionable” than the other sources of antiquity. Still, at the end of the day, making something “less questionable” or “the lesser of two evils” does not eliminate it from being still “questionable” or “evil.” Deeming something “less heretical” does not make it “orthodox,” so deeming the Gospels “less historically questionable” does not make them “historically accurate.” Evans’s damage control did not control...rather, it damaged the Gospels’ reliability even further.
Ehrman made it clear quite a few times in the debate that “I want you all to know that Dr. Evans is agreeing with me.” At one point in the debate he said, “I expected to have a debate where the opponent actually disagreed with me,” laughing to express how unbelievable the debate really was. These remarks are telling, indeed: the fact that Dr. Bart Ehrman was given “academic high-fives” from Dr. Evans shows just how horrible of a debate it really was. What has gone wrong in our world when the evangelical scholar begins to agree with the agnostic scholar about Jesus?
In the concluding remarks in the debate on Friday night, both got a chance to reiterate their points. Ehrman made it clear that the Baptist Faith and Message 2000 stated that the Bible contains “no mixture of error.” And yet, according to Ehrman’s evidence, the Bible contained historical inaccuracies that Dr. Evans could not explain away (nor did he try).
What did Evans say to end it all? He made an analogy between the Book of Proverbs and the Gospel of John:
“In Proverbs,” he asked, “Does not Lady Wisdom speak truth? Yes she does. But is there an actual Lady Wisdom speaking truth here? Do these events literally happen? No. Rather, the emphasis is not on what literally happened, but the truth that was spoken. When you come to the Gospel of John, Jesus is representing Lady Wisdom here, speaking truth. Remember what John says about Christ, that He is ‘the Logos’ (the Word)?”
I’m pretty sure that you will not find these exact words from the recorded conference itself in this order. It’s very likely that I am paraphrasing Evans’s words above. However, I have not lost the gist of Evans’s argument; he attempted to say something without being explicit about it. The fact that he said “Jesus is representing Lady Wisdom” in the Gospel of John ought to send off the mental light bulb in our minds. To see what Evans is saying, let’s set up a syllogism:
Premise #1: Proverbs is about Lady Wisdom speaking truth. However, there is no specific person speaking here (just personification).
Premise #2: In the Gospel of John, Jesus (as “Logos”, the Word) is representing Lady Wisdom speaking truth.
Conclusion: If Jesus is representing Lady Wisdom, then He, like Lady Wisdom, did not literally say the things recorded about Him. The emphasis is not that He literally spoke truth, but the true words He spoke.
Dr. Evans did not actually say the conclusion in his ending remarks; he simply left it to the evangelical mind to “fill in the blanks” of his argument. What he was trying to get at was that John’s Gospel is all about “the Johannine community’s affirmations about Jesus,” not that Jesus actually said and did the things that are written of Him. This has problems, however, when one comes to the biblical text.
I would say more, but time will not permit it. Despite the sad debate, I had a great time down in New Orleans with my brother Billy Birch and the Provost of New Orleans Baptist Theological Seminary, Dr. Steve Lemke. In my next post, I will tackle Evans’s words regarding the Gospel of John and its questionable historicity. Keep reading...